1. Home
  2. Cruise Reviews
  3. Celebrity Silhouette
Celebrity remains our favourite line despite cruises on P & O, Cunard and Royal Caribbean. We were booked in a Celebrity Suite but as my wife has mobility problems and really needs a walk in shower( not present in Celebrity Suite) we were lucky to get a last minute cancellation for a Royal Suite at greatly reduced price.The Suite is very similar to a Celebrity Suite but with the walk in shower and a bigger balcony with a Jacuzzi - rather grubby and remained unused. There are Sky Suites with disability features but at the stern end of the ship and in any case were unavailable.Perks included unlimited specialty restaurants ( became useful - see below) and a premium drinks package - not much use as my wife doesn't drink but it did mean a much nicer glass of wine with my dinner. The butler Jackie and suite attendant Jose were superb.This is being a bit picky but the suite needs the refurbishment that is coming soon - the table in the room was badly worn and the carpets looking a bit drab. We were in Luminae restaurant where we have dined before. The staff - from maitre'd Claire downwards were excellent and it was not their fault that the food was so disappointing. The menu is very limited and most people were asking for the menu from the MDR. The portions were tiny, especially the vegetables which often arrived tepid. On our last night my steak was of motorway service cafe standard. In fact the best evening meals we had were when we chose to eat upstairs in the Ocean View Restaurant (twice) and made use of our speciality dining perk to eat in the Grill on the Lawn (twice)where the food, especially the steaks, were of the highest standard. We tried Cuisine once but whereas it was previously a great experience we found it gimmicky, again with a very limited menu. We preferred breakfast and lunch in the Ocean Cafe - a bit crowded but much greater choice than in Luminae. All stops pulled out on last day's lunch in the Ocean View - choice of beef,lamb.turkey carvery,barbecued chicken, Indian,Chinese,Mexican, incredible cakes and a white chocolate fountain with fruit kebabs.(to my surprise only gained 5lb over the two weeks. Entertainment not of the highest order. The days of flying out big names are over. A good 60's group on first night(The Overtones) and a Jersey Boys type group(East Coast Boys) on last night - not bad but Franky Valli needn't worry. There were several silent discos held in the main foyer. Silent in name only - any attempt at conversation in Baccios two floors up was almost impossible. Don't know why they don't have these in the Sky Lounge on 14. The place sounded like a rowdy party night on Independance. That probably sounds pompous but Celebrity has always been a bit more sophisticated than Royal Caribbean. Often there are problems with shuttle services at ports for those with mobility scooters but we had excellent service in this respect at La Spezia and Lisbon. We enjoy the quizzes for daytime entertainment and the two entertainment officers who did these - Chantelle and Ryan were great and well liked by the participants. All in all a very enjoyable cruise with just a few grumbles.

Lowering of standards?

Celebrity Silhouette Cruise Review by docberg

5 people found this helpful
Trip Details
Celebrity remains our favourite line despite cruises on P & O, Cunard and Royal Caribbean.

We were booked in a Celebrity Suite but as my wife has mobility problems and really needs a walk in shower( not present in Celebrity Suite) we were lucky to get a last minute cancellation for a Royal Suite at greatly reduced price.The Suite is very similar to a Celebrity Suite but with the walk in shower and a bigger balcony with a Jacuzzi - rather grubby and remained unused. There are Sky Suites with disability features but at the stern end of the ship and in any case were unavailable.Perks included unlimited specialty restaurants ( became useful - see below) and a premium drinks package - not much use as my wife doesn't drink but it did mean a much nicer glass of wine with my dinner. The butler Jackie and suite attendant Jose were superb.This is being a bit picky but the suite needs the refurbishment that is coming soon - the table in the room was badly worn and the carpets looking a bit drab.

We were in Luminae restaurant where we have dined before. The staff - from maitre'd Claire downwards were excellent and it was not their fault that the food was so disappointing. The menu is very limited and most people were asking for the menu from the MDR. The portions were tiny, especially the vegetables which often arrived tepid. On our last night my steak was of motorway service cafe standard. In fact the best evening meals we had were when we chose to eat upstairs in the Ocean View Restaurant (twice) and made use of our speciality dining perk to eat in the Grill on the Lawn (twice)where the food, especially the steaks, were of the highest standard. We tried Cuisine once but whereas it was previously a great experience we found it gimmicky, again with a very limited menu.

We preferred breakfast and lunch in the Ocean Cafe - a bit crowded but much greater choice than in Luminae. All stops pulled out on last day's lunch in the Ocean View - choice of beef,lamb.turkey carvery,barbecued chicken, Indian,Chinese,Mexican, incredible cakes and a white chocolate fountain with fruit kebabs.(to my surprise only gained 5lb over the two weeks.

Entertainment not of the highest order. The days of flying out big names are over. A good 60's group on first night(The Overtones) and a Jersey Boys type group(East Coast Boys) on last night - not bad but Franky Valli needn't worry.

There were several silent discos held in the main foyer. Silent in name only - any attempt at conversation in Baccios two floors up was almost impossible. Don't know why they don't have these in the Sky Lounge on 14. The place sounded like a rowdy party night on Independance. That probably sounds pompous but Celebrity has always been a bit more sophisticated than Royal Caribbean.

Often there are problems with shuttle services at ports for those with mobility scooters but we had excellent service in this respect at La Spezia and Lisbon.

We enjoy the quizzes for daytime entertainment and the two entertainment officers who did these - Chantelle and Ryan were great and well liked by the participants.

All in all a very enjoyable cruise with just a few grumbles.
docberg’s Full Rating Summary
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Service
Onboard Experience
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get Celebrity Silhouette price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email

Cabin Review

Royal Suite
Cabin RS 1116
See above. Spacious suite and balcony. Great walk in shower.
Furniture and carpets need refurbishing.
Penthouse Deck Inside Cabins, Balcony Cabins, Suite Cabins

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews