1. Home
  2. Cruise Reviews
  3. Celebrity Edge
We sailed on the Celebrity Edge on the April 26th to May 13th, 2019 trans-Atlantic (TA), crossing. Check-in was fast and efficient. We downloaded and used the Celebrity app. That allowed us to scan in our passports and photos so upon arrival we were able to quickly pass through check-in and make our way onto the ship. Bravo to Celebrity for updating the process and creating the app. Once onboard, we were able to access our rooms quickly and our baggage arrived shortly after we got into our cabin. Our sea pass was awaiting us at our cabin door. Our cabin was a sunset veranda, # 11274, and this sailing represented our 4th TA in a sunset veranda so for the purpose of full disclosure, we were predisposed to like the location and aft cabin experience. We were not disappointed. Our cabin was well laid out, had sufficient room and the location at the back of the ship was perfect for us. The bathroom was spacious, and the shower seemed larger than we have experienced on previous ships. The water pressure and temperature were excellent. The bathroom counter space was enough for our needs. The balcony was longer than normal sized balconies but to us, it seemed shorter than previous sunset cabin verandas and although the balcony could have accommodated two loungers, it only had two chairs and a very small table. We like to sit on the balcony and enjoy the sunrise or sunsets. Loungers would have been much better and added comfort. We ended up using the small table as a foot-rest which was not the best option. The cabin itself was well maintained and “Andi”, our cabin attendant was excellent. He did an outstanding job of keeping the cabin in perfect condition and always greeted us by name and with a smile on his face. The cabin was bright, well appointed and had a large mirror sporting “surround lighting” at the dressing table. The size and lighting was appreciated and useful. We found that the dresser/counter space was limited and made more so by the “Celebrity books” and paraphernalia already occupying the limited counter space. We ended up placing the books under the bed to give us more counter space. Overall we would give the room a 4.5 out of 5. Because we did not stay in an Infinite Veranda room, I will not rate those type of cabins but I will pass on some general comments. The rest of the people in our group (14), all had Infinite Verandas so we were able to see a number of them first hand and we heard the pros and cons. Most of our group were not fans of the cabins as they felt they never got the outside experience. One likened it to having an oversized window that you could “sometimes” open. Apparently the ship’s staff have the ability to lock the mechanism(s) so they could not open the “verandas” when the seas were deemed too rough. The people in our group were all on decks 8 or 9 so fairly high up. Consequently, some felt that there should not have been the need to block the ability to open the veranda. The verandas were also described as restrictive, noisy and limiting views. The ship itself has some positives and negatives. I would be remiss if I did not mention the art around the ship. I am not speaking of the usual art found on ships that is later placed for sale, but specifically the art used as part of the ship’s décor. Well done Celebrity! We loved the different pieces and the mixture of styles. The overall appearance of the ship is fabulous. Definitely a 5 out of 5. The buffet on deck 12 was very good and the selection for the most part was excellent. The morning staff were always in attendance to fill up the coffee and bring juice etc. At lunch time they were not as visible and at times it was difficult to find bar staff. However, we were generally there for the food and there was a wide selection and usually very good. 5 out of 5. The idea of four main dining rooms is in my opinion, an epic fail. We had made reservations in advance of our sailing for every night of our sailing and in the different dining rooms. We knew we might want to make changes to dine with friends but thought that paying the extra for Select dining would allow for ease in making changes. Quite the opposite, if we needed to change reservations, we ran into problems. Additionally, there were variations in the quality of food and service in different rooms and if you had a bottle of wine in one restaurant, and dined at another the next night, it took awhile to get your wine. We found that the Normandie was the poorest restaurant in terms of service and food quality. There were a few times when the meal that arrived was cold or there were delays in getting some dishes. The result was that a person might be still waiting for their meal when the others at the table were almost done their main course. Additionally, the first night we were dining with a number of friends and we were given a table with chairs on one side and padded bench style seating on the other. The seating was so low that the four people on that bench style seating were uncomfortably low and likened it to be a child at table that was too tall for them. By the end of the cruise we were avoiding the Normandie and focused on any of the other restaurants. Overall the food in all the restaurants was unremarkable, uninspired and average. The Cyprus and Tuscan came out on top for service and quality so we were trying to eat there and that meant navigating the restaurant change process and it was not a fun or easy process. 2 out of 5 for the four main dining rooms. We tried three specialty dining venues. The Eden experience lived up to the hype and was a delight. Entertaining, delicious and memorable, it was an excellent meal and overall super evening. The entertainers were enjoyable, the open meal preparation fun, and the service impeccable. The food was exceptional. We would definitely pay the extra money to enjoy that experience again. 5+ out of 5. The Fine Cut Steak House was so/so. It is positioned two decks above the martini bar and is open to the bar and common area below. That means all the noise that is occurring below, is heard in the restaurant. As a result, one’s conversation is in competition with shouts, music and other noise from the two open decks below. Consequently, the ambiance is somewhat lacking. The food was good but not exceptional. We all had the steak which was OK but two were overcooked. The décor was average and overall, the dining experience was average and not worth expending the extra money. 2 out of 5 Le Petite Chef was a fun experience. The animation was entertaining, and the serving staff were excellent. The food was very good and we would repeat the experience again, if only to get better video of the entire dinner preparation. We imagine that the animation would wear thin after awhile, but for now, we highly recommend people give it a try. 5 out of 5. The entertainment on average was good and although we did not attend a lot of shows, those that we did attend (4) were entertaining and enjoyable. The seating was comfortable and although we sat in different locations, we always enjoyed a clear field of vision. 5 out of 5 with the caveat that we took in a smaller number of shows and there are others who can provide a better review of the entertainment. The emergency drill was excellent with video screens employed so everyone had a good view. The staff were, for the most part excellent and friendly. There was a high degree of visibility for senior staff and the Captain was entertaining with his 10am morning updates. We would recommend the ship, the cruise line and in support of that statement, I can confirm that we booked two future cruises while onboard.

Excellent Cabin, Fantastic Ship Appearance and Mixed Restaurant Results

Celebrity Edge Cruise Review by PaleGale55

11 people found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: April 2019
  • Destination: Transatlantic
  • Cabin Type: Sunset Veranda Stateroom
We sailed on the Celebrity Edge on the April 26th to May 13th, 2019 trans-Atlantic (TA), crossing.

Check-in was fast and efficient. We downloaded and used the Celebrity app. That allowed us to scan in our passports and photos so upon arrival we were able to quickly pass through check-in and make our way onto the ship. Bravo to Celebrity for updating the process and creating the app.

Once onboard, we were able to access our rooms quickly and our baggage arrived shortly after we got into our cabin. Our sea pass was awaiting us at our cabin door.

Our cabin was a sunset veranda, # 11274, and this sailing represented our 4th TA in a sunset veranda so for the purpose of full disclosure, we were predisposed to like the location and aft cabin experience. We were not disappointed. Our cabin was well laid out, had sufficient room and the location at the back of the ship was perfect for us.

The bathroom was spacious, and the shower seemed larger than we have experienced on previous ships. The water pressure and temperature were excellent. The bathroom counter space was enough for our needs.

The balcony was longer than normal sized balconies but to us, it seemed shorter than previous sunset cabin verandas and although the balcony could have accommodated two loungers, it only had two chairs and a very small table. We like to sit on the balcony and enjoy the sunrise or sunsets. Loungers would have been much better and added comfort. We ended up using the small table as a foot-rest which was not the best option.

The cabin itself was well maintained and “Andi”, our cabin attendant was excellent. He did an outstanding job of keeping the cabin in perfect condition and always greeted us by name and with a smile on his face.

The cabin was bright, well appointed and had a large mirror sporting “surround lighting” at the dressing table. The size and lighting was appreciated and useful. We found that the dresser/counter space was limited and made more so by the “Celebrity books” and paraphernalia already occupying the limited counter space. We ended up placing the books under the bed to give us more counter space.

Overall we would give the room a 4.5 out of 5.

Because we did not stay in an Infinite Veranda room, I will not rate those type of cabins but I will pass on some general comments. The rest of the people in our group (14), all had Infinite Verandas so we were able to see a number of them first hand and we heard the pros and cons. Most of our group were not fans of the cabins as they felt they never got the outside experience. One likened it to having an oversized window that you could “sometimes” open. Apparently the ship’s staff have the ability to lock the mechanism(s) so they could not open the “verandas” when the seas were deemed too rough. The people in our group were all on decks 8 or 9 so fairly high up. Consequently, some felt that there should not have been the need to block the ability to open the veranda. The verandas were also described as restrictive, noisy and limiting views.

The ship itself has some positives and negatives. I would be remiss if I did not mention the art around the ship. I am not speaking of the usual art found on ships that is later placed for sale, but specifically the art used as part of the ship’s décor. Well done Celebrity! We loved the different pieces and the mixture of styles. The overall appearance of the ship is fabulous. Definitely a 5 out of 5.

The buffet on deck 12 was very good and the selection for the most part was excellent. The morning staff were always in attendance to fill up the coffee and bring juice etc. At lunch time they were not as visible and at times it was difficult to find bar staff. However, we were generally there for the food and there was a wide selection and usually very good. 5 out of 5.

The idea of four main dining rooms is in my opinion, an epic fail. We had made reservations in advance of our sailing for every night of our sailing and in the different dining rooms. We knew we might want to make changes to dine with friends but thought that paying the extra for Select dining would allow for ease in making changes. Quite the opposite, if we needed to change reservations, we ran into problems. Additionally, there were variations in the quality of food and service in different rooms and if you had a bottle of wine in one restaurant, and dined at another the next night, it took awhile to get your wine.

We found that the Normandie was the poorest restaurant in terms of service and food quality. There were a few times when the meal that arrived was cold or there were delays in getting some dishes. The result was that a person might be still waiting for their meal when the others at the table were almost done their main course. Additionally, the first night we were dining with a number of friends and we were given a table with chairs on one side and padded bench style seating on the other. The seating was so low that the four people on that bench style seating were uncomfortably low and likened it to be a child at table that was too tall for them. By the end of the cruise we were avoiding the Normandie and focused on any of the other restaurants. Overall the food in all the restaurants was unremarkable, uninspired and average. The Cyprus and Tuscan came out on top for service and quality so we were trying to eat there and that meant navigating the restaurant change process and it was not a fun or easy process. 2 out of 5 for the four main dining rooms.

We tried three specialty dining venues. The Eden experience lived up to the hype and was a delight. Entertaining, delicious and memorable, it was an excellent meal and overall super evening. The entertainers were enjoyable, the open meal preparation fun, and the service impeccable. The food was exceptional. We would definitely pay the extra money to enjoy that experience again. 5+ out of 5.

The Fine Cut Steak House was so/so. It is positioned two decks above the martini bar and is open to the bar and common area below. That means all the noise that is occurring below, is heard in the restaurant. As a result, one’s conversation is in competition with shouts, music and other noise from the two open decks below. Consequently, the ambiance is somewhat lacking. The food was good but not exceptional. We all had the steak which was OK but two were overcooked. The décor was average and overall, the dining experience was average and not worth expending the extra money. 2 out of 5

Le Petite Chef was a fun experience. The animation was entertaining, and the serving staff were excellent. The food was very good and we would repeat the experience again, if only to get better video of the entire dinner preparation. We imagine that the animation would wear thin after awhile, but for now, we highly recommend people give it a try. 5 out of 5.

The entertainment on average was good and although we did not attend a lot of shows, those that we did attend (4) were entertaining and enjoyable. The seating was comfortable and although we sat in different locations, we always enjoyed a clear field of vision. 5 out of 5 with the caveat that we took in a smaller number of shows and there are others who can provide a better review of the entertainment.

The emergency drill was excellent with video screens employed so everyone had a good view. The staff were, for the most part excellent and friendly. There was a high degree of visibility for senior staff and the Captain was entertaining with his 10am morning updates.

We would recommend the ship, the cruise line and in support of that statement, I can confirm that we booked two future cruises while onboard.
PaleGale55’s Full Rating Summary
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Fitness & Recreation
Service
Onboard Experience
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get Celebrity Edge price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Cabin Review

Sunset Veranda Stateroom
Cabin SV 11274
Our cabin was a sunset veranda, # 11274, and this sailing represented our 4th TA in a sunset veranda so for the purpose of full disclosure, we were predisposed to like the location and aft cabin experience. We were not disappointed. Our cabin was well laid out, had sufficient room and the location at the back of the ship was perfect for us.
The bathroom was spacious, and the shower seemed larger than we have experienced on previous ships. The water pressure and temperature were excellent. The bathroom counter space was enough for our needs.
The balcony was longer than normal sized balconies but to us, it seemed shorter than previous sunset cabin verandas and although the balcony could have accommodated two loungers, it only had two chairs and a very small table. We like to sit on the balcony and enjoy the sunrise or sunsets. Loungers would have been much better and added comfort. We ended up using the small table as a foot-rest which was not the best option.
The cabin itself was well maintained and “Andi”, our cabin attendant was excellent. He did an outstanding job of keeping the cabin in perfect condition and always greeted us by name and with a smile on his face.
The cabin was bright, well appointed and had a large mirror sporting “surround lighting” at the dressing table. The size and lighting was appreciated and useful. We found that the dresser/counter space was limited and made more so by the “Celebrity books” and paraphernalia already occupying the limited counter space. We ended up placing the books under the bed to give us more counter space.
Overall we would give the room a 4.5 out of 5.
Deck 12 Inside Cabins, Balcony Cabins, Suite Cabins

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews

  • Bilbao Old Quarter
    Not my favourite stop. We travelled to Castro Urdiales to see the castle, cathedral and the old light house and then followed that up with a visit to the old quarter in Bilbao. We were a bit rushed and frankly, I would not recommend trying to do both on the same shore excursion.
    View All 7 Bilbao Old Quarter Reviews
  • Golfing
    We booked an 18 hole golf package through the Port Royal golf course. The course offers a cruise ship special which includes 18 holes, golf clubs, cart, balls and shoes.
    The course is amazing, visually appealing and somewhat challenging. Loved the experience.
    View All 6 Golfing Reviews
  • Sete Cicades Crater Lake Tour
    I booked three (3) vans for this tour. The trip went well and the vans were clean, the drivers knowledgeable and the experience good. We went to the hot springs, the Sete Circades Crater Lake and the town of Ponta Delgada. Over-all we liked the tour and really enjoyed some aspects to it. However there is not all that much to see. The day was overcast so the green and blue lakes looked the same colour. Some of the scenery was breathtaking.
    View All 37 Sete Cicades Crater Lake Tour Reviews
  • Stonehenge
    Stonehenge, always fascinating and this time we lucked in with the weather. Beautiful day but the good weather also brought out the crowds so the line ups were long.
    View All 28 Stonehenge Reviews