We booked this cruise based upon the ship , not the itenary We are experienced cruisers and wanted to try the Edge. From the ease of embarkation, to the design of the ship, to the shows, it was excellent. We booked a 4 night Specialty Dining package. Very disappointed that you couldn’t book in advance. Prime time dining was taken. We were part of a Group of 12. We dined twice in Fine Cuts and were wowed with the service and the food. They put us in a private room. We also dined outdoors in Eden and the barbecue was great. Very disappointed in Tuscan. Food and service were well below par. Normandy was wonderful and the service markedly improved when we mentioned our dissatisfaction. This is a great ship and Celebrity designed it for the sophisticated traveler. Plenty of shade by the pool, raised whirlpools that were actually hot elevated walking track. The cabin was great the infinity window far surpasses the balcony door. Overall a great ship