Disappointed: MSC Poesia Cruise Review by Joe Josephson

MSC Poesia 2
Joe Josephson
Member Since 2010

Overall Member Rating


Sail Date: March 2010
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Fort Lauderdale (Port Everglades)
This is a case of "you get what you pay for". We travelled with our two children during their Spring Break. Most other cruise prices were much higher for the four of us so we chose this cruise though we had never heard of MSC cruises before. A travel agent that our family frequently uses did warn us in advance that MSC offers a European style cruise that may not be what we Americans have grown to expect out of cruises with the better known lines. She was right on.

The boarding process was actually very smooth though we were not able to determine the earliest time we could board. Therefore, though we arrived in Ft. Lauderdale the day before the cruise, we ended up killing time in Ft. Lauderdale the day of the cruise which was scheduled to depart at 7:00 p.m. We assumed we would not be able to board before 2:00. Upon arrival we discovered that we could have boarded as early as 11:00 a.m.

The cabin was as expected. We had received an "upgrade" to the 12th deck. The More room included a balcony. The only disappointment with this room was the fact that considerable banging noises occurred from above all evening, late into the night, and very early in the morning. We discovered that this was likely due to the fact that the Foosball and ping pong tables were directly above our cabin and the crew moved tables and chairs around late at night and early in the morning on the deck above us--lesson learned on cabin location.

In general the food was surprisingly bland. At first the quality of the food was poor including poor cuts of meat and over cooked meat. This gradually improved through the cruise--either due to complaints or the desire to improve customer comments at the end of the cruise. We usually opted for the alternative menu items (steak, salmon, spaghetti, etc.) as a result of our disappointment with the daily menu items. Most of the items in the breakfast and lunch buffets were nicely presented but tasted bland or just plain bad. The desserts were not very good either.

The nightly shows in the theater were mediocre at best. Every night the same dancers performed as did one singer. The dancers were out of sync every night. It was as if they had never rehearsed together. The singer was very good but she was the only one singing the entire cruise. There were a few acrobat acts. Each was very short and again repeated about every other night. The shows in general were too short and lacked variety.

The ship is well-maintained as it should be since it is only a couple of years old. The cabin crew did an excellent job of keeping our cabin in shape. Our waiter was also very good though seemed to be indifferent towards us during breakfast on the disembarkation day. I've noticed this phenomenon at the end of most cruises. In this case, since the tips are automatically added to the final bill, the waiter was probably not concerned about us since it was too late for us to adjust the tips.

The fitness facility was poorly maintained. Several of the pieces of equipment were out of order from the beginning of the trip and were never repaired. Some of the remaining equipment did not work properly. Variety of resistance machines was minimal.

Bottom line--Though the price was extremely competitive, I would not recommend MSC cruises to anyone. Less

Published 04/05/10

Cabin review: 1112063

Noisy location. Banging from deck above. Great view since it was a balcony room.

Port and Shore Excursions

We opted to go this on our own. No excursions. We took a cab to the shopping district. Nothing interesting and we've done this before. Constantly harassed by merchants.

Read 5490 Cozumel Reviews

In Key West we opted to go it on our own--no excursions. Not far from the ship we came across an individual offering a bicycle-based buggy ride through the town. This was a wonderful way to go. He peddled slowly through the town frequently stopping to tell the history of the town and the background of many of the buildings and homes. This was our second trip to Key West via cruising. This was by far the better experience. I highly recommend this mode of touring.

Read 1392 Key West Reviews

We opted for going it on our own vs. using the cruise line excursions. We found a cab driver who offered to stay with us for a few hours as he drove us to our destination which was rafting in Martha Brae. He charged us $70 for this service which included a guided tour along the route to Martha Brae and back. At Martha Brae we were charged $60 per raft (two on each raft). In the end the cost of this approach was very close to the excursion price offered by MSC though we did receive more personal attention including a side trip to an ATM and through Falmouth past the former home of Jamaican sprinter Ben Johnson.

At Martha Brae we endured an extremely long wait for rafts. Our tour guide was able to use his influence to allow us to bypass a large tour group. However, due to an inoperative vehicle used to tow rafts back to the start of the trip, there was a period of time of around 45 minutes during which no rafts appeared. In the end we waited about 1 hour and 30 minutes for our rafts. The experience was worth the wait. The rafting was wonderful and the surroundings were beautiful.

We've been to Nassau a few times. This was the most pleasant experience. The town was very enjoyable. It seems as though Nassau has improved over time. We experienced snorkeling for the first time through the cruise excursion. This was well worth the cost. We loved snorkeling though the weather was a bit chilly that early in the morning.

One of my favorite parts of this port was the view that we had from the 15th deck of the Poesia which appeared to be higher than most any structure on the island itself.

Read 5044 Nassau Reviews

Compare Prices on MSC Poesia Western Caribbean Cruises

Read more MSC Poesia cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s MSC Poesia Review >>

Compare Prices on MSC Poesia Western Caribbean Cruises

Joe Josephson
Member Since 2010
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Skip X

See MSC Poesia deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
MSC Poesia 50% Loved It

6 Night Mediterranean Cruise
See all MSC Poesia Deals >>