We sailed from 2/17 - 2/24/19 and visited ports in the Western Caribbean. We booked our cruise when it first went on sale - so glad we did as the price went up significantly since then. Overall, loved the Edge! It is apparent lots of thought went into the design, art, etc. It is definitely a different concept than prior ships. Would probably have given it a rating of 5 if there had been a few modifications.
Restaurants - We enjoyed all four main dining rooms, and also tried Le Petit Chef and Eden. Overall the food was very good. The wait staff are extremely accommodating and friendly.
As for Eden, I can understand why some cruisers think it is strange. However, the food is fantastic! We also interacted with our wait staff and the Edenists (interactive characters) and learned about their story. It made for an interesting experience that helped us appreciate Eden even more. Loved that location during the day, also!