There's a lot to love about the Edge, but given the price I'm not sure we'd return. We did a B2B of the Western/Eastern Carribean.
Pros:
-- Cabin was beautify, although there were some functional misses. Since our cruise the "iconic rocking chair" has come out. It was too big and there were no places to enjoy room service. I believe that's being fixed.
Lovely cabin. Bed faces the water, which is really great. Otherwise, I described much of the cabin in my review.