1. Home
  2. Cruise Reviews
  3. MSC Seaview
We sailed in Yacht Club in MSC Seaview just two days after doing a week cruise in MSC Fantasia YC. Yacht club is probably the most affordable way to get an executive experience in the cruise but unfortunately bigger ship made it almost less luxurious experience. The embarkation in Barcelona went smoothly. Once again we did not even have time to finish a glass of sparkling wine when a butler was ready to accompany us to the ship. The YC cabin in Seaview is bigger than in Fantasia and the space divider between the sofa and the bed gives a nice touch to the cabin. There seemed to be though less room for the clothes and other stuff while there is no more a separate walk-in closet. The bathroom is better than in older ships while we prefer the shower to the bathtub. The YC restaurant in Seaview is upstairs of the Top sail lounge. It is nice if you do not wish to leave the YC premises but to us it really made no difference. You can enter the restaurant either from lounge or the cabin corridor. The crew still needs to improve the way receiving guests and giving them a table. Some evenings there seemed to be lack of tables. The restaurant has not really bad tables but some are still better than others. We needed to ask for one every night as we did not want to sit in the last corner of the restaurant. The food is no special and it resamples to the one of the main restaurant. The menu was total the same as in Fantasia a week before although the presentation was a bit better. There are always a couple of wines available and sadly the most common question was only “red or white”. The sommelier performed a pretty ridiculous show to those buying a bottle from the list. One evening I requested a wine from the YC normal wine list that caused the sommelier to explain to me that they know better that I should drink. He made the same speech to the neighbor table who wanted to buy a “wrong” bottle. I found this rather rude considering that the menu and the (open) wines had really nothing to do with wine pairing. Otherwise the waiters managed to tackle through the dinner but that´s it. The service in public areas were extremely slow. Some of the drink waiters did not even know the cocktail list (which is practically the same in every venue) and ordering something else caused confusion. I think that an appletini (or apple martini) is quite a common drink but it was impossible to get one even in the Top sail lounge. Getting Miami Vice (once again rather common drink) took ages even in One pool while they really had to find a person who knew what that is. Good was still that they really worked to find somebody recognizing this. The One pool buffet was a chaos in the breakfast and even worse in lunch time. At lunch they probably had a good selection of dishes but I still do not know what they are. First you had to make it through to the buffet and then you should figure it out what they could do from the ingredients. Same in the mornings. Ordering a salmon meant that you got five minutes later a peace of grilled salmon but nothing else. When you needed to take the plate and tried to get the sides from the buffet. The sides meant overcooked vegetables. The salad bar was so minimal that I would not even call it a joke. The buffet had some general fruits but it was strange to notice that the public buffet had much better selection offering even “specialties” like cherries and strawberries. The lay out of the One pool is much worse than in the older ships. The lounge chairs and tables are mixed. The pool area is rather crowded. A small pool and two whirlpools are situated in the different sides of the area. There are no lounge chairs that would have some shadow. I have nothing against children in the YC but I still think that the whole YC is no playground for the children and some behavior is awaited. All we needed from the concierge was to make a reservation to the Butcher cut. She made that but when we went for a dinner there was no reservation. In Seaview where are some special restaurant as the older ships have practically none. We tried the Butcher cut and have never felt us so unwelcome as in that restaurant. We were seated in a table made for four people and it took 3 crew members to understand that we are not waiting any company and we were allowed to make an order. The food was nothing special and it was total overpriced. The service was hurried and nonchalant compared to what you usually get when eating in a special restaurant on a cruise. We really felt no need to test the other special restaurants after the first experience. The public buffet had always a lot of empty tables. Unfortunately the guests made it very chaotic. Some people do not know what a queue means and some were even eating from the buffet. The food is nothing special. The different dishes are on different stations which are situated quite far from each other so collecting a plate means a lot of walking. The shows were rather strange. MSC had visited the other cruise lines and have updated their shows compared to the older style. The result is a strange mix of Celebrity style feature shows with Italian flare. This means dancers with feathers and peculiar outfits, second class acrobats (all of them in the same show), 5 singers singing everything from opera to pop hits. And all this, all together in 30 minutes. Disembarkation is one of the best parts of YC experience. You can have your breakfast and when you are ready your butler will walk you out from the ship. In the terminal one of our bags were missing. The butler did all he could to find out what have happened. Probably another guest have left the ship before us and have taken our bag instead of his. They tried to reach the passenger but did not manage. After a week our bag has not been found. The rules of MSC they say that the handling company in the harbor is responsible for the bags. The handling agent made us fill in a form that we could give to our insurance company. It feels that nobody is even trying to get the bag back to us. After doing Fantasia (and Divina before) I would consider recommending YC to my friends but I have doubt if I would still do it. Bigger is not always better and to our experience this certainly is so in a cruise as well, no matter if it is RCCL, NCL or MSC. A bigger ship seems to mean lack of personal service.

Bigger is not always better

MSC Seaview Cruise Review by phi

4 people found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: July 2018
  • Destination: Mediterranean
  • Cabin Type: Yacht Club Deluxe Suite
We sailed in Yacht Club in MSC Seaview just two days after doing a week cruise in MSC Fantasia YC. Yacht club is probably the most affordable way to get an executive experience in the cruise but unfortunately bigger ship made it almost less luxurious experience.

The embarkation in Barcelona went smoothly. Once again we did not even have time to finish a glass of sparkling wine when a butler was ready to accompany us to the ship. The YC cabin in Seaview is bigger than in Fantasia and the space divider between the sofa and the bed gives a nice touch to the cabin. There seemed to be though less room for the clothes and other stuff while there is no more a separate walk-in closet. The bathroom is better than in older ships while we prefer the shower to the bathtub.

The YC restaurant in Seaview is upstairs of the Top sail lounge. It is nice if you do not wish to leave the YC premises but to us it really made no difference. You can enter the restaurant either from lounge or the cabin corridor. The crew still needs to improve the way receiving guests and giving them a table. Some evenings there seemed to be lack of tables. The restaurant has not really bad tables but some are still better than others. We needed to ask for one every night as we did not want to sit in the last corner of the restaurant. The food is no special and it resamples to the one of the main restaurant. The menu was total the same as in Fantasia a week before although the presentation was a bit better. There are always a couple of wines available and sadly the most common question was only “red or white”. The sommelier performed a pretty ridiculous show to those buying a bottle from the list. One evening I requested a wine from the YC normal wine list that caused the sommelier to explain to me that they know better that I should drink. He made the same speech to the neighbor table who wanted to buy a “wrong” bottle. I found this rather rude considering that the menu and the (open) wines had really nothing to do with wine pairing. Otherwise the waiters managed to tackle through the dinner but that´s it.

The service in public areas were extremely slow. Some of the drink waiters did not even know the cocktail list (which is practically the same in every venue) and ordering something else caused confusion. I think that an appletini (or apple martini) is quite a common drink but it was impossible to get one even in the Top sail lounge. Getting Miami Vice (once again rather common drink) took ages even in One pool while they really had to find a person who knew what that is. Good was still that they really worked to find somebody recognizing this.

The One pool buffet was a chaos in the breakfast and even worse in lunch time. At lunch they probably had a good selection of dishes but I still do not know what they are. First you had to make it through to the buffet and then you should figure it out what they could do from the ingredients. Same in the mornings. Ordering a salmon meant that you got five minutes later a peace of grilled salmon but nothing else. When you needed to take the plate and tried to get the sides from the buffet. The sides meant overcooked vegetables. The salad bar was so minimal that I would not even call it a joke. The buffet had some general fruits but it was strange to notice that the public buffet had much better selection offering even “specialties” like cherries and strawberries.

The lay out of the One pool is much worse than in the older ships. The lounge chairs and tables are mixed. The pool area is rather crowded. A small pool and two whirlpools are situated in the different sides of the area. There are no lounge chairs that would have some shadow. I have nothing against children in the YC but I still think that the whole YC is no playground for the children and some behavior is awaited.

All we needed from the concierge was to make a reservation to the Butcher cut. She made that but when we went for a dinner there was no reservation. In Seaview where are some special restaurant as the older ships have practically none. We tried the Butcher cut and have never felt us so unwelcome as in that restaurant. We were seated in a table made for four people and it took 3 crew members to understand that we are not waiting any company and we were allowed to make an order. The food was nothing special and it was total overpriced. The service was hurried and nonchalant compared to what you usually get when eating in a special restaurant on a cruise. We really felt no need to test the other special restaurants after the first experience.

The public buffet had always a lot of empty tables. Unfortunately the guests made it very chaotic. Some people do not know what a queue means and some were even eating from the buffet. The food is nothing special. The different dishes are on different stations which are situated quite far from each other so collecting a plate means a lot of walking.

The shows were rather strange. MSC had visited the other cruise lines and have updated their shows compared to the older style. The result is a strange mix of Celebrity style feature shows with Italian flare. This means dancers with feathers and peculiar outfits, second class acrobats (all of them in the same show), 5 singers singing everything from opera to pop hits. And all this, all together in 30 minutes.

Disembarkation is one of the best parts of YC experience. You can have your breakfast and when you are ready your butler will walk you out from the ship. In the terminal one of our bags were missing. The butler did all he could to find out what have happened. Probably another guest have left the ship before us and have taken our bag instead of his. They tried to reach the passenger but did not manage. After a week our bag has not been found. The rules of MSC they say that the handling company in the harbor is responsible for the bags. The handling agent made us fill in a form that we could give to our insurance company. It feels that nobody is even trying to get the bag back to us.

After doing Fantasia (and Divina before) I would consider recommending YC to my friends but I have doubt if I would still do it. Bigger is not always better and to our experience this certainly is so in a cruise as well, no matter if it is RCCL, NCL or MSC. A bigger ship seems to mean lack of personal service.
phi’s Full Rating Summary
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Service
Onboard Experience
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get MSC Seaview price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Cabin Review

Yacht Club Deluxe Suite
Cabin YC1 16016
The YC cabin in Seaview is bigger than in older ships and the space divider between the sofa and the bed gives a nice touch to the cabin. There seemed to be though less room for the clothes and other stuff while there is no more a separate walk-in closet. The bathroom is better than in older ships while we prefer the shower to the bathtub.
Caribbean Deck Inside Cabins, Suite Cabins