1. Home
  2. Cruise Reviews
  3. Magellan
We chose this because of the departure point of Dundee and the itinerary. Embarkation from Dundee was seamless. Cabin 5138 comfortable fairly roomy with plenty of storage space. Bathroom adequate did not like the generic shampoo/body wash in dispensers (bring your own if you can). Mary kept room spotless and always acknowledge us. Cabin very noisy. We ate early sitting in Waldorf service exceptional. Many people tried to alter from late sitting there were many empty seats but people were told they could not change . Tip ask again after a couple of days. We ended up eating all our meals in Waldorf due to the terrible scrum in Raffles Bistro. Selfish fellow passengers sat there on sea days not moving from one meal to the next. Food was adequate some meat was tough, puddings used fake cream no steaks or lobster but pasta fish and veggie option always available and beautifully presented. Midnight buffet was spectacular but people behaved appallingly pushing and grabbing. Many of them had finished eating at ten o clock! Due to bad weather we had 5 sea days and this put a strain on the facilities. It was difficult to get anywhere to sit to read or simply chat. Talks were well attended. Excursion team explained excursions but were not pushy. Non English speakers. made it difficult to understand them. Show lounge very busy with people keeping seats and waiting from the end of the first performance until the second. Some restricted views because of pillars. Entertainment was mixed dancers and orchestra good solo violinist superb singers dreadful and host irritating. Staff on the whole friendly and efficient they were mostly eastern European I missed the easy going charm of the Malaysians and Indonesians who worked on my previous cruise ships. The exception to this was the \reception staff who with one exception (the young man) were abrupt and rude. this was commented upon by several fellow guests they need to be retrained. Most people were over seventy and many had mobility problems. If you are looking for non stop execitment this isn't the ship for you. On the whole we had value for money

More than 'average' but not 'very good'

Magellan Cruise Review by ALBAGUBRATH

11 people found this helpful
Trip Details
We chose this because of the departure point of Dundee and the itinerary. Embarkation from Dundee was seamless. Cabin 5138 comfortable fairly roomy with plenty of storage space. Bathroom adequate did not like the generic shampoo/body wash in dispensers (bring your own if you can). Mary kept room spotless and always acknowledge us. Cabin very noisy.

We ate early sitting in Waldorf service exceptional. Many people tried to alter from late sitting there were many empty seats but people were told they could not change . Tip ask again after a couple of days. We ended up eating all our meals in Waldorf due to the terrible scrum in Raffles Bistro. Selfish fellow passengers sat there on sea days not moving from one meal to the next. Food was adequate some meat was tough, puddings used fake cream no steaks or lobster but pasta fish and veggie option always available and beautifully presented. Midnight buffet was spectacular but people behaved appallingly pushing and grabbing. Many of them had finished eating at ten o clock!

Due to bad weather we had 5 sea days and this put a strain on the facilities. It was difficult to get anywhere to sit to read or simply chat. Talks were well attended. Excursion team explained excursions but were not pushy. Non English speakers. made it difficult to understand them. Show lounge very busy with people keeping seats and waiting from the end of the first performance until the second. Some restricted views because of pillars. Entertainment was mixed dancers and orchestra good solo violinist superb singers dreadful and host irritating.

Staff on the whole friendly and efficient they were mostly eastern European I missed the easy going charm of the Malaysians and Indonesians who worked on my previous cruise ships. The exception to this was the \reception staff who with one exception (the young man) were abrupt and rude. this was commented upon by several fellow guests they need to be retrained.

Most people were over seventy and many had mobility problems. If you are looking for non stop execitment this isn't the ship for you. On the whole we had value for money
ALBAGUBRATH’s Full Rating Summary
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Shore Excursions
Service
Onboard Experience
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get Cruise & Maritime Voyages Magellan price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews