• Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Log In
Celebrity Eclipse Cruise Review
4.5 / 5.0
Cruise Critic Editor Rating
1,923 Reviews

Worthy of their reputation

Celebrity Eclipse Cruise Review by bambam

1 people found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: Apr 2018
  • Destination: the Southern Caribbean
  • Cabin Type: Concierge Class 3

This was our 15th Cruise, 2nd on Celebrity. The Eclipse is exceptionally clean, well maintained, and has a crew that appears to be happy and helpful.

The Oceanview Cafe by far was the best designed “buffet” we’ve experience, bright, roomy, and with many many options to choose. The staff were constantly clearing tables and getting drinks, and the food servers were polite and gave portion size based on request.

The dining room, the Moonlight Sonata (deck 3) also was brightly decorated, but with some of the worse chairs. If you sat up, you had no back support, and if you leaned back, you slouched. However, the food was consistently some of the best meals we’ve ever had on the high seas. Salmon and beef dishes were perfect, time after time. Appetizers and Desserts were different and very tasteful. Unfortunately for us, we had a server team that was one of the slowest ever; we found out on the last day that our main server was quitting and it reflected in his service. The poor assistant was learning and appeared confused most of the time. Simply stated, their service “dance” was not in sync. On the plus side, our sommelier was amazing, a walking smile and happy happy guy. I wrote him up as the best crew member on the ship. We don’t drink alcohol or wine, but I gave him an extra tip, because he earned it.

We were blessed to have the best cabin attendant ever as he kept the cabin in perfect order, provided extra towels as needed, and gave us our 3:00pm snack on time every day. His attitude of being happy, helpful and joking nature was greatly appreciated.

We saw a few shows, they were well presented, but on a personal note, we both have problematic knees. In sitting in the theater chairs, they were comfy, but had a slight downward tilt (aged?) that at the end of the show, made it very painful for us to even stand up. So after multiple different seats, we gave up and stopped going. Like I said, more of a personal issue than a ship issue.

Being a cruise critic member, I don’t believe we’ve use any ship/line excursion except for the 12-metre yacht race in St. Maarten. Unfortunately, the 3-yachts were damaged by the hurricane and not an option. We spent this cruise checking out all inclusive resorts at the various ports. Some good, some not so good. It was a learning experience.

Lastly, we have to say that getting the consigliere service was a huge plus for us. We parked our car offsite at Safepark (no issues whatsoever) and was dropped off at 10:30am. We were on the ship at 11:00 checking spa appointments out as well as discovering the Eclipse. At 11:30, we had the private lunch in the Moonlight Sonata and didn’t have to deal with the cattle call in the buffet. The daily treats in the cabin were nice, but the better cabin steward was extra special. Lastly, the early debarkation time was also sweet as we walked off at 8:00 (after a special breakfast meal), got our luggage, the parking lot shuttle showed within 10 mins, and at 9:00, we were on 95 heading north.

Except for the slow dining service and the seats in the theater, the Eclipse met and exceeded our expectations. Thank you Celebrity!

bambam's Full Rating Summary
Onboard Experience
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Public Rooms
Fitness & Recreation
Sign Up for Price Drop Alerts
Get tomorrow's price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Cabin Review

Concierge Class 3
Cabin C3 1134

A very nice balcony cabin designed as a king bed set up. The closet was a little cramped, and the cabinets over the bed were roomy, and different. There is a lack of drawer space, so Pebbles used the ones in the cabin and I used the ones in the bathroom. Probably the most spacious bathroom we’ve had, so many shelves that several were left empty. The shower was a roomy circular shower with sliding doors, an adjustable shower head, and plenty of shampoo, conditioner, body lather and body lotion. The balcony was roomy with a table, two adjustable chairs and footstools. Loved having morning breakfast and evening relaxation times listening to the ocean. Sigh.... see my main review to hear about the exceptional cabin steward.

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews

St. Maarten

We went to the shops by the pier and bought some items we probably didn’t need, but wanted to help the locals as best we could. It was sad to see a few of the buildings downtown still covered with blue tarps. So sad. My fav port, but couldnt do the 12-meter yacht race because the three sloops were destroyed by the hurricane.


We went to Jolly Beach All Inclusive Resort. The facility was nice, but aged. The staff was very nice. Unfortunately, the entrance to the water on the beach had a significant “dip,” causing many folks to slip and fall, including Pebbles, who hurt her knee and shoulder. Otherwise, a good day and nice location, but not worth looking at for a weeklong vacay.

St. Lucia

Due to the fall at Jolly Beach, we stayed on the ship. But the rest did good as we were able to go off the ship in Barbados.


We went to the Hilton, and bad luck continued as the resort had the red flag warnings up due to high/rough waves and riptides. It was a Hilton, excellent beach, very nice pools, and the meal service was very good. But it was not an all inclusive: they gave us vouchers for 1-main course and 1-drink. But a nice resort!


What made this stop nice was we had planned on a break from the all inclusive resort search. So Pebbles relaxed on the ship while our dining room sommelier went with me to show me a public cove near the ship that had some decent snorkeling. Spent 90-minutes snorkeling with him and it was all he talked about in the dining room. A class guy!


Probably our best island visit in a while. We met two couples (Arizona and Canada) who were looking for a third couple to go to Blue Bay Beach Club. It was about 20-mins by taxi, and when we got there, we realized we had been there years ago. Absolutely a lovely beach, easy in and out of the water, lounge chairs and umbrellas for $8.00 per person, and reasonable food and beverages nearby. Excellent snorkeling in the cove with some great pictures. The best!!


Let’s just say it was a case of misinformation. We went to the Amsterdam Manor Resort (on Eagle Beach). When we got there, the counter gal told us they couldn’t let us use the beach chairs, so they gave us “a $10 credit for the chair rentals.” So we went to the beach, got a couple of chairs, and a few mins later, a chair hawk shows up and kicks us off the chairs. Back to the office, a few words later, and we got a complete refund with a cab ride back to the ship. Seems none of the hotels are allowed to rent beach chairs, a relatively new law. So on Eagle Beach, 2-chairs and an umbrella will cost you $45. On day two in Aruba, we did some shopping for last minute gift items and went back to a quiet ship.

Previous ReviewNext Review
7 Reviews Written
1 Helpful Votes
Never Miss a Deal!
Subscribe and Save
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

More Celebrity Eclipse Reviews

Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.