We tried Oceania. We have cruised Silverseas and seaborne. The ship focuses on food. Our recent cruise was loaded with elderly very large folks. These folks cannot board buses or walk very well. They hobble down the halls clogging up the isles.
Also because of the limited physical abilities of the passengers the off ship excursions are geared to large inanimate viewing.
This ship is in need of either a serious cleaning or time to refurbish. The carpet in our suite was dreadfully stained and worn.
As stated above the carpet is in dire need of cleaning at minimum but should be replaced. The bathroom sink was cracked. The bathroom mirror was separated from its frame. Very dangerous sharp edges