We live close to Tampa so we decided to take the quick after New Year's cruise to Cozumel. I have been on several cruises with RCCL as well as NCL and Princess. If our next, already scheduled RCCL cruise is not any better, we may be permanently opting for other lines.
Our room was clean and the attendant attended to it however, I didn't feel the extras. For example, we had towel animals 2 of the 4 evenings, even though I mentioned to the attendant how much my 12 year old looks forward to them. Also, as I have read in the past, the furniture in the room, as well as all over the ship looks old and worn. The chair in our room was stained as well as the chairs in The Colony Club public space area.
We enjoyed the mini golf and the ping pong. However, the ping pong area is very close to the smoking section of the pool deck and we had to stop playing a couple of times because the smell of smoke was so strong.