We had a great time on this ship. It was beautiful. We did not like the separate kids pool. Our kids are older and we didn't enjoy hanging in a pool packed with toddlers. Ropes course was fun as well as the slides.
We only eat the buffet and it was great! Really liked all the burgers with toppings on them near the pool. The cabins are much better than on the Epic, but the pool area is much better on the Epic. We are not big broadway show folks which seems to be what all the ship are leaning towards, so we didn't like the shows. The brew pub was cool and was never even half full. Kind of a hidden gem. Kids enjoyed the kids club as usual.
Really wish they would move some of the activities like Bingo and Deal out of the atrium as there isn't enough room.