Cabin lacked many things that were to be included in this class. Afternoon "snacks" we're very poor. Had terrible time with booking a table for dinner in anytime dinning. Never had such a difficult experience as this. Definitely not worth the Conciege level. Cruise director,Sue , was very good and brought good entertainers on board. However the Singers and Dancers main Shows were not very good and have gone down in quality and spectacular feeling. Acrobatic portions excellent. Some cast singers did not sing but Yelled the music. Found overall sound system in the theatre set to a very loud decibel level making it necessary to put earplugs in many cases. Cabin attendand Nicol was excellent. Wish you had supervised Bridge games with a Bridge teacher. Overall, there are cuts on spending in many levels and perhaps this is felt a bit too much. The elegance of Cruising is weakening.