The disembarkation did not go smoothly. They need to station two staff members on each floor to guide the guest out. There was no staff on the 2nd floor to guide us to where to go to disembarkation. It was confusing. But after all we were guided off the ship. The staff and service were excellent. At midnight there need to be a another food area open instead of pizza pirates. The line was very very long, but we finally got our pizza. I would travel again on the carnival liberty but have my room in the middle of the ship. Our room was located in back of the ship, we felt every part of the ship moving side to side with the rough water. The dining experience was wonderful, the staff were good bring out food to us quickly and hot. They were very friendly. The steward for our room was excellent. Clean linen!