• Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Log In
Arcadia Cruise Review
4.0 / 5.0
Cruise Critic Editor Rating
447 Reviews

Very eventful cruise ......

Arcadia Cruise Review by lovethe7seas

15 people found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: Sep 2017
  • Destination: Canada & New England
  • Cabin Type: Deluxe Stateroom with Balcony and Bath/Shower

Hope you are prepared for this!

We started well, a very quick check in and cases already in cabin when we arrived. Windy and cold when we left so no real sail away party. Usual lifeboat drill, with cabin cards being checked to make sure everyone attended (a bit of a shambles in the theatre with some people who didn't show their card and never got asked for it). Then back to complete unpacking and ready for dinner.

First sitting on table for six and delightful table companions. One couple had been upgraded to a suite so at that point felt quite jealous....

First night a little windy but nothing untoward however it gradually increased - force 7, force 8, until one evening yes, you guessed it force 10..... (so glad I had taken my seasick tablets!!) However I felt Arcadia coped well, although the bangs, bumps and creaking did cause several comments.

I no longer felt jealous of , our now friends , in the suite as it was situated at the stern right over the propellers and very very noisy and bumpy in their cabin.

It was five days before we could really venture outside safely. No swimming pool neither - far too dangerous. But it was lovely being rocked to sleep each night.

Finally got into New York which was extremely busy and very hot (Donald Trump and United Nations in town!!!!!) Very high security everywhere and lots of roads closed off to traffic so our taxi driver had to drop us off in the middle of the road.

Then the fun started again, New Port missed because the hurricane was catching up, made Boston safely in the pouring rain but Bar Harbor missed because again bad weather catching up.

Eventually got safely into Halifax where we had a trip to Peggy's Cove which was far too short - about 40 minutes there- then back on board ready to leave. BUT NO - a rope tight around asipod so we were stuck!

So instead of sailing away for Saguenay we stayed in Halifax and the next day we wandered into the quayside. By the way, we had to berth much further down than usual so we had to use a shuttle bus just to get out of the secure area where we were.

Then we had to miss Saguenay and straight on to Quebec for our two day stay-Wrong Again we didn't arrive until 9 pm the first day so one day there missed. Second day in Quebec was lovely. Bright and sunny.

THEN as we prepare for sail away the captain informed us that instead of going on to Sydney we were going to head BACK to Saguenay as that was a much nicer port sailing up the fiord . If anyone does go to Saguenay, the "La Fabuleuse " show is not to be missed. It is absolutely amazing, brilliant, wonderful.....

However by this time many people were very unhappy as missing out on tours, disappointed at missing seeing relatives and often general lack of information.

Personally, hubby and I felt the captain did the best he could and the excursion staff went all out to rearrange tours and put on additional ones for people where possible. Total of three ports missed and shortened stay in Quebec.

Of course this further change to the itinerary meant six days at sea coming home instead of five.

However P&O did compensate a bit with the odd bribe here and there.....

BUT FOR US the icing on the cake was on the third day into the cruise whilst in the middle of the Atlantic we booked a further cruise -ON ADONIA! Eight days later we joined a large queue of people trying to find a new cruise to book...honestly the loyalty manager didn't even know about the sale of Adonia..

Arcadia is still a good ship although perhaps a little tired in places. Unfortunately several couples had to move cabin because of leaks etc - one couple three times, but she is going in for a full refit in November when all these problems will be solved (hopefully).

The food in the MDR was excellent. Plenty of choice and as much as you wanted if you asked. The Headliners on this cruise were the best we have seen on any cruise and we thoroughly enjoyed the shows. The entertainment manager was also brilliant and really worked hard as did his team. Other entertainment varied but I always feel it is personal choice - I didn't like the second show by the comedian but hubby did! I loved the local dance team brought on -but hubby didn't.

The usual Art and Bridge classes were well attended and there were plenty of interesting talks etc every day.

Overall I think it was a good cruise despite lots of problems and as usual all the P&O staff on board were brilliant and couldn't do enough for you. Can not say the same for the shop staff who are often quite rude and pushy.

Next cruise in May is on Oriana for the first time but we will certainly go back to Arcadia as soon as possible.

lovethe7seas's Full Rating Summary
Onboard Experience
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Public Rooms
Fitness & Recreation
Shore Excursions
Sign Up for Price Drop Alerts
Get tomorrow's price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Cabin Review

Deluxe Stateroom with Balcony and Bath/Shower
Cabin DC C60

Good size cabin. Plenty of wardrobe space and drawers in bedside cabinets. Tons of room under beds for suitcases etc. Extremely comfortable mattress and choice of pillows.

Table, chair and settee. Usual fridge, hairdryer, safe etc.

All kept spotless by cabin steward.

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews


Quincy market a great place to wander around.

Peggy's Cove

Lovely place with plenty to see but you need lots of time there to wander around. Unfortunately we only had 40 minutes!!

View All 245 Peggy's Cove Reviews
Quebec City

Wonderful place with lots to see and do within easy walking distance of ship.

Previous ReviewNext Review
1 Reviews Written
15 Helpful Votes
Never Miss a Deal!
Subscribe and Save
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

More Arcadia Reviews

Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.