We chose this for the itinerary and knowing the small ship (old Renaissance III). The itinerary was great and it was the perfect trip to escape the heat in the US. The ship had just come out of dry dock so there were a few things that were unfinished (like cushions on the deck furniture) and the seals on the sliding glass cabin doors. Embarkation and disembarkation were so fast and easy. We loved the new Club Class even though the "new" furniture was not in place in the dining room. We were blown away by the Club Class dining and service. The dining service staff and bar staff could not do enough for you! By day three, the wait staff knew your name and what you liked and disliked. We were a bit disappointed to miss one port, Scrabster, Scotland, due to storms and high seas but overall this was one of our favorite cruises. My only suggestion would be to add a few extra activities during the many sea days.