Celebrity Over Rated - But Alaska Was Not: Celebrity Infinity Cruise Review by Camillka

Celebrity Infinity 4
Member Since 2009

Overall Member Rating

Celebrity Over Rated - But Alaska Was Not

Sail Date: September 2009
Destination: Alaska
Embarkation: Seattle
Since we were driving from Portland to Seattle to embark, I made parking reservations with Republic Parking NW and paid for Cruise Only parking in advance. This is covered parking directly across from the Bell Street Pier. We arrived at 11:45 AM and within 15 minutes, they had tranferred our luggage to the ship and shuttled us to the Cruise Terminal. Since no one could board before noon, there were many people, but it still seemed to go quite rapidly. The mistake the cruise ship made, was to hand out a form at the entrance, that did not have to be completed until you had gone through customs. But people stopped in line and tried to fill them out, which only caused greater confusion.

However, all in all, the process was quick. We had a glass of champagne and boarded the ship and went to our Stateroom. Our travel agent touted this as a 5 Star cruise line, but it was no where near that. The Staterooms were worn, the bedding was pilled and worn, the chairs had upholstery hanging More down from underneath, our television for on line ship information did not work, the carpeting was very worn and all in all, we found the room to be quite tacky. Sadly, although nice, our Stateroom Attendant, just didn't seem to be enthusiastic in his attitude.

There are three other down sides that we experienced. The carpeting on three of the decks (that had bars in them) smelled of urine when we would walk through. This was for the entire trip. And, as many other passengers experienced, we did not appreciate a camera in our faces whenever we embarked, disembarked, attended a formal dinner or any other activity that the ship could consider a photo op. And lastly, one of the entertainers, the magician would not have made it to the next round on America's Got Talent. He act needs a lot of work.

The food choices in the dining room were superb!! You could always order from the menu of the first evening dinner along with the menu of the day. The selections were excellent. The buffet was the same every day, but the way it is set up is very confusing and someones people coming from both entrances meet in the middle and jockey for position. The various buffet themes are very poorly marked and you have to go to different sections of the room, to find different "themes". We found it confusing, even after several days. Also, the buffet is not open 24 hours, which is disappointing. Room service however, is available 27/7, and although free and fast service to your room, the selection is very limited. And one last thing, on the topic of food, outside of the dining room there are limited low fat and low salt options. And, they use a lot of oil.

The spa and gym are great although in the gym they have baskets of fruit and flowers out of plastic that are faded and dusty and again very very tacky. The library is great and they try to offer many options of interest for you to participate in during the day.

Since the Hubbard Glacier is not a Port of Call, I want to say that it was just spectacular. The Captain was able to get the cruise ship within 3/10th of a mile and we enjoyed a wonderful afternoon at the glacier.

There were two things that I observed that bother me greatly. The first is that you are not required to use Purel boarding the ship, entering the dining room or buffet, etc. On Royal Caribbean, staff stood and required each passenger to use Purel. The lack of this requirement on Celebrity concerns me.

On the last day of the cruise as we were disembarking, the "security staff" didn't even glance at our passport and one of the security people was just standing at the bottom of the escalator laughing and goofing off. Security was poor at best.

However, at the terminal we got a porter, who took us to our Cruise Only Parking Shuttle and we were back on the road to Portland in under 15 minutes. We highly recommend Republic Parking NW. Less

Published 09/22/09

Cabin review: Sr

Great closet space. Smaller than other staterooms of other cruise ships. Very worn overall. The carpeting was worn and faded, chairs had upholstery hanging down from underneath, on line cruise information menu on television did not work, the bedding was worn as was the bedspread. The room was not at all appealing.

Port and Shore Excursions

I have been to Juneau before, so it was a treat to return. On the pier we stopped at the Visitor Center (a neutral spot) with staff that can get you anywhere you want to go at a very reasonable price.........they can recommend buses and local transportation that again, is a fraction of the cost of the cruise line packages. We went to Mendenhall Glacier and spent a great part of the day. The weather was partly cloudy and rather comfortable. We took a hike on path to Nugget Falls, which was worth the time. We of course, spent a lot of time viewing Mendenhall. After returning to downtown Juneau, we walked to the infamous "Red Dog Saloon" but it so reeked of beer and so loud and crowded that we decided to get a beer elsewhere. It just wasn't the ambiance I remembered from my last visit. We walked up the street to the Capitol Cafe (popular with the politicos) in the Westlake Hotel. Lunch was absolutely superb and the waitress made a few suggestions of what to see and how to spend some of the rest of our day. We did walk up the hill to the historical Russian Orthodox Church, but it was locked, so the visit was brief. Instead, we headed back downtown and went to the Alaska State Museum. What a great experience, and the layout and presentation is worth the visit. They have also added in May 2009, the NOAA sphere that rotates and changes viewings of weather, fires, glaciers, etc. of the world over many years. On the way back to boarding the ship we went to "The Harbor" bar and grill. It overlooks the water and we were able to watch seaplanes take off and land. It was there that we met two locals and we all enjoyed a wonderful conversation. Quite a wonderful day.

Read 1188 Juneau Reviews

We disembarked and booked our own excursion and saved half the price of the Ship's shore excursion packages. And using AAA, we received another discount. The advantage to booking on shore, is you can taylor it specifically to your interests. We used RainBird for our excursion. The tour driver (Earl) was incredibly knowledgeable. This was one of the best tours we have experienced. He was extraordinarily entertaining in the most professional manner. We saw spawning salmon, eagle, totems and Ketchikan in general. After the tour, we visited the "local" shops and steered clear of the mass production jewelry and souvenir shops.

Read 1342 Ketchikan Reviews

The only thing to say about Victoria, is see as much as you can while you are there. It is one of the most beautiful cities in North America. We took a city bus from the pier to downtown and bought a ticket to Butchart Gardens. Again, our bus driver was brilliantly interesting. Sadly, we were there on Sept. 17th and two days earlier, was the last day that the gardens stayed open into the evening. No matter. The day was glorious and the gardens are always a treat.

Read 876 Victoria Reviews

Compare Prices on Celebrity Infinity Alaska Cruises

Read more Celebrity Infinity cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Celebrity Infinity Review >>

Compare Prices on Celebrity Infinity Alaska Cruises

Member Since 2009
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Celebrity Infinity deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Celebrity Infinity 71% Loved It

7 Night Pacific Coastal Cruise
See all Celebrity Infinity Deals >>