This was not my first Carnival cruise and to be on a boat with 4,000 guests was way over crowded. Never have I had to wait in line for food as we did on the Magic. The entertainment was not the best. Granted Dr. E was fabulous for any of his performances, the rest of the entertainment was poor. Normally, comedy night was ever night. Not here, plus they did the same shows again at the end of the week. On a previous trip on the Liberty the DJ played music each day in the afternoon to keep the party going. Not on the magic, it was select days. The food was not the best. Have had better food on previous trips. Those who would say the food was great obviously have not eaten "good" cruise food. The dining room service was very slow and if you had a large appitite you would have had to order 2 meals. One thing there was a lot of drinking on this boat. I would really have to think twice about this ship again and the larger boat. . DJ Bonez seemed to have a chip on her shoulder, possibly being on a boat for 9 years has taken away how to be friendly to people.