Carnival Miracle from NYC - Recommended!: Carnival Miracle Cruise Review by Island Boy Cruiser

Carnival Miracle 5
Island Boy Cruiser
Member Since 2008
7 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

Carnival Miracle from NYC - Recommended!

Sail Date: September 2009
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: New York (Manhattan)
This is my 11th cruise on Canival and we loved it! We got engaged on our last cruise (Feb. 09 on the Carnival Freedom), so at least this time there were no "jitters". This was the first time leaving from NYC. No airfare and Amtrak was only $70.00 round trip (per person).

Embarkation - no issues - we had the VIP treatment, due to the number of cruises that we have done. We were on board by 12:30 P.M., eating lunch and having the drink of the day! The Miracle - tastfully decorated. Lot's of color and blown glass. I have been on the Spirit and the Legend so I knew the layout.

The Room - we usually get a category 11 with a military rate. there was no military rate this time so we went with a category 9A, room 7299. I was a little nervous because finding pictures of a 9A can be tricky. I have some and will try to post them. The room was great. Very roomy, plenty of closet space and the balcony was just as big as the category 11. Bathroom was smaller than the More category 11, but was still done in tile and was very spacious. We were right next to the elevators and never (I mean never) heard them! We were 4 decks above the restaurant, so you could smell the food from time to time.

The islands - we visited Grand Turk, Half Moon Cay, and Nassau.

The food - very good. Nice selection in the dining room and in the buffet area. Nick and Nora's Supper Club was outstanding! The food and service was out of this world. The service - our room steward (Budi) was fabulous! We introduced himself the first day and called us by name everytime he saw us. The room and towels were always made up and in stock. Our head waiter (Earl) was very good too, but he never learned any of our names. My only issue with the dining room was that the head waiters don't seem to have Ass't waiters anymore. They seemed to be stretched a little to thin. The bar staff and waitress were also outstanding (Savatlana was #1).

The entertainment - very good comedians, magicians, and ventriloquists. The dance club was fun too. However, the last few cruises I have been on the Piano Bar player has been terrible. This is usually a fun hang out, but yikes, Carnival needs to get a musician with a pulse. Too many slow, droopy songs played over and over and over. The bands were very good too, big props to Double Cross, a band from PA that had 35 peeps with them - they played twice and were great! The Cruise Director, Malcolm (in the middle yoo-hoo) was very, very good. Energetic, introduced himself to everyone, and tried to get as many people involved as possible in all of the events.

Overall - great cruise - great staff - would do it again!

Halfmoon Cay - Private Island

Outstanding Beach and some of the best water I have ever seen! Free chairs for the beach and all of the watersports for a reasonable fee. Free lunch on the beach too! A great beach bar that took the sail and sign card (SWEET).

We swam and feed the stingrays here. Very fun. Was able to hold a Starfish, Conch, and Sea Cucumber too! The staff was very friendly, energetic, and interactive.

I would go back here in a minute. Less

Published 09/15/09
1 Helpful Vote

Cabin review: 9A7299 Premium Balcony (obstructed views)

Catergory 9A - room 7299. Next to the elevators, never heard them. Outstanding for the price. Almost as big as a suite. Balcony is as big as a suite. Plenty of closets and drawers. Bathroom was spacious and done in tile. I have pictures of the room and will post them.

Read All Premium Balcony (obstructed views) (9A) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

Very pretty island with great water. A Margarettaville is right there with some very small shops. Our excursion was cancelled and we only found out a day in advance so the others ones that we would have considered were already sold out. We had purchased our excursions in April. The Margarettaville is only opened when there is a cruise ship in port. The entertainment was great, music, and drinking. You have to buy the CD that the DJ sells with "The Big Bamboo" song, it is so funny (only $10.00). The swim up bar is great. It's also nice that they offer free chairs at the pool and the beach. DO NOT go to Governer's Beach - what a waste. $3.00 cab ride for a mile walk. The chairs are $10.00 to rent and the beach is nasty.
Read 1695 Grand Turk Reviews

Went to the Atlantis for the Water Park and the Deep Swim with the Dolphins.

Water Park - what else can I say about a 75 foot and a 120 foot straight down water slide....AWESOME! There was also about 15 pools, hot tubs, and much easier water slides to do.

Deep water Swim with the Dolphins - a litte pricey, but well worth it. Not only did you get to hold and pet them, but you got on a boogie board and they pushed you around the lake. We also got to use a power scooter and dive and swim with them underwater. You do get to keep the snorkeling gear. They take plenty of photos with you interacting with the dolphins and they are pricey also. But, be ready for food and drink prices at the Atlantis...very, very pricey. Two hot dogs and a water: $19.00.

Read 5024 Nassau Reviews

Compare Prices on Carnival Miracle Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Miracle cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Miracle Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Miracle Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Island Boy Cruiser
Member Since 2008
7 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Miracle deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Miracle 76% Loved It

7 Day Mexican Riviera Cruise
See all Carnival Miracle Deals >>