We choose the Arcadia because of the destinations she was going to, my husband and I had never been to some of the country's before. Having sailed on the Britannia we didn't think twice about sailing with P&O again. Embarkation was perfect and we were pointed in the direction of our cabin. Our cabin was somewhat tired looking to say the least and the windows so filthy it was had to see out, on investigation of the rest of the ship every window on the ship was the same making it very difficult at times to see anything. The noise from the bar above our cabin gave us a late night before sleep and a early morning wake up call when beer barrels were being changed and chairs moved back into place, we asked if we could be moved and we were to over the engine room!! The dreadful smell by the shopping area lasted the whole cruise as did the water dripping through the ceiling into buckets, and once onto me god knows what this water is? The food in the Belvedere was sometimes rather bland even though everyday we had curry on the menu. I have never lost weight on holiday before but managed to come home 3lbs lighter. Constant pestering by waiters from the bar, ocean grill and the Sindhi restaurant trying to get you to spend more money while trying to eat your meal became unbearable. To top it off the fire alarm went off and there was an incident in the Paladin theatre. The entertainment was very good and the shore excursions were fine except Cagliari where you are swamped by Street sellers not a nice place to go, nothing to see either P&O would be better off forgetting this place and spending more time in Gibraltar. Black tie evenings is an enjoyable part of cruising for some!! but for those passengers who do not wish to dress up (as this is their holiday after all and they pay the same for their holiday as everyone else), they are not allowed into large areas of the ship on those occasions, why? very unfair don't you think. Poor staff working very long hours with no days off, no wonder they all looked fed up and no one was smiling you might get the odd one give you a smile but you would be lucky. Reception staff were wonderful as were the cabin staff.This boat yes I am calling her a boat as until she has a complete refit and the staff have better working conditions she doesn't deserve to be called a SHIP.

Very tired ship

Arcadia Cruise Review by Shearwater29

10 people found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: April 2017
  • Destination: Europe
We choose the Arcadia because of the destinations she was going to, my husband and I had never been to some of the country's before. Having sailed on the Britannia we didn't think twice about sailing with P&O again. Embarkation was perfect and we were pointed in the direction of our cabin. Our cabin was somewhat tired looking to say the least and the windows so filthy it was had to see out, on investigation of the rest of the ship every window on the ship was the same making it very difficult at times to see anything. The noise from the bar above our cabin gave us a late night before sleep and a early morning wake up call when beer barrels were being changed and chairs moved back into place, we asked if we could be moved and we were to over the engine room!! The dreadful smell by the shopping area lasted the whole cruise as did the water dripping through the ceiling into buckets, and once onto me god knows what this water is? The food in the Belvedere was sometimes rather bland even though everyday we had curry on the menu. I have never lost weight on holiday before but managed to come home 3lbs lighter. Constant pestering by waiters from the bar, ocean grill and the Sindhi restaurant trying to get you to spend more money while trying to eat your meal became unbearable. To top it off the fire alarm went off and there was an incident in the Paladin theatre. The entertainment was very good and the shore excursions were fine except Cagliari where you are swamped by Street sellers not a nice place to go, nothing to see either P&O would be better off forgetting this place and spending more time in Gibraltar.

Black tie evenings is an enjoyable part of cruising for some!! but for those passengers who do not wish to dress up (as this is their holiday after all and they pay the same for their holiday as everyone else), they are not allowed into large areas of the ship on those occasions, why? very unfair don't you think.

Poor staff working very long hours with no days off, no wonder they all looked fed up and no one was smiling you might get the odd one give you a smile but you would be lucky. Reception staff were wonderful as were the cabin staff.This boat yes I am calling her a boat as until she has a complete refit and the staff have better working conditions she doesn't deserve to be called a SHIP.
Shearwater29’s Full Rating Summary
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Fitness & Recreation
Shore Excursions
Service
Onboard Experience
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get Arcadia price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email

Cabin Review

Cabin G107
Tired looking, not enough 13amp sockets, windows outside filthy, bed against window so even more difficult to see out. I found a pack of ladies pants down the back of the bedside bottom drawer preventing it from shutting properly, bedding tired, carpet tired. Bathroom cheap fixtures nasty shower curtain and with a non operating extraction fan.
  Arcadia Deck Plans

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews

  • Dubrovnik
    Having found Split so beautiful with it shops, market, cafes and palm trees we didn't think Dubrovnik would be any better. On walking into the city with its vast marble floor it seems impossible that nearly 60% of this old town was destroyed by the war, now completely restored there are alleyways everywhere full of beautiful arts and crafts eateries and coffee shops. Music floats though the alleys and you are drawn towards a duo playing a classical piece on the cello and violin. This is heaven in a walled city.
    View All 1,174 Dubrovnik Cruise Port Reviews
    View Cruise Critic's Dubrovnik Cruise Port Review
  • Rock of Gibraltar
    A Mini bus took us up the rock which was a fab experience and dropped us at the caves. The caves were illuminated with coloured lights making a spectacular sight. On exiting the caves the monkeys were out in force to greet us. Our mini bus took us back down the Rock and as on the way up pointed out interesting facts and places. A quick wall around the town then back to the ship lovely trip but only 5hrs allowed in Gibraltar which was not nearly enough time.
    View All 94 Rock of Gibraltar Reviews
  • Sardinia
    Don't go here.......... you will be swamped with street traders most of whom have travelled the 26 odd miles from Morocco, or if you of course need a fridge magnet, sunglasses, or a tea towel by all means go. Apart from some shops along the Main Street there was nothing to see, perhaps if you had a car it maybe better, but even the shore excursions ladies told us that Cagliari was not set up for tourists. We lasted a full 1.5 hours had a coffee fought off another three street traders while drinking said coffee then made our way back to the ship with our heads down saying no thank you, no thank you, no, no, off, get off, go away etc
    View All 252 Sardinia Cruise Port Reviews
    View Cruise Critic's Sardinia Cruise Port Review
  • Seville
    Pretty little place with cafes and a few market stalls selling necklaces and bracelets. Don't take the local tour bus so Cadiz it will cost you approximately £18 each and although you see the seafront you also go to some really shoddy areas.
    View All 387 Seville Cruise Port Reviews
    View Cruise Critic's Seville Cruise Port Review
  • Southampton
    Very efficient, we didn't wait long at all and we were boarding the ship.
    View All 967 Southampton Cruise Port Reviews
    View Cruise Critic's Southampton Cruise Port Review
  • Omis Walking Tour
    Beautiful quaint village with little shops and cafes. The river runs by Omis and all to soon we were leaving and on our way to our restaurant. On arrival we were meet with musicians food and wine then off again on a river boat for a 40 minute trip which left us breathless at the shear beauty of the area
    View All 2 Omis Walking Tour Reviews
  • Taormina (Messina)
    Coach to Taormina to independently spend time breathing in the sights. Beautiful place lovely shops, spent time in the beautiful park which overlooks the coastline. Simply a time to relax drink coffee eat gelato and people watch, all to soon it's back to the ship
    View All 12,780 Taormina (Messina) Cruise Port Reviews
    View Cruise Critic's Taormina (Messina) Cruise Port Review
  • Burano Island
    Very pretty place, many little lace shops and places to eat and drink coffee. Watching the dying art of lace making was a true privilege produced by an elderly lady using just one needle. The lace is very expensive but it takes days to produce a small item.
    View All 33 Burano Island Reviews
  • Murano Island
    Lovely trip to Murano to see how they make the famous Murano glass which was very interesting then escorted into the shop to view the items for sale. Affordable if you like brightly coloured animals such as rearing horses but there were also beautiful twisted stemmed wine glasses. Murano glass is a dying art so we were told buy it while you can.....
    View All 54 Murano Island Reviews