Carnival Victory Earns A++++!!!: Carnival Victory Cruise Review by ilovecruisin43713

Carnival Victory 5
Member Since 2009

Overall Member Rating

Carnival Victory Earns A++++!!!

Sail Date: July 2009
Destination: Southern Caribbean
Embarkation: San Juan
We embarked in San Juan on 7/26 for a 7 day cruise with 7 ports of call.  I have cruised with other lines before (Royal Caribbean, Princess) so was a little apprehensive about Carnival as they have not always gotten good press.  Not having cruised with Carnival before, I was pleasantly surprised that this cruise was at the same standard as the other cruises on which I have been a passenger.  They exceeded my expectations!!!  Each night we were greeted by Gede and Adhi, our head waiter and waiter.  They were always pleasant, courteous, knew our drink preferences, called us by name, and made great dinner recommendations!  The bar staff was always equally friendly!  We made acquaintance with Edwin in the sports bar, he will tend to your needs very well!  The food on this cruise was great, not SUPERIOR but great.  I would rate it to be equivalent to both Royal Caribbean and Princess' fare.  The buffet restaurant (Mediterranean Restaurant) More was always hot and good.  However, for breakfast, I would recommend going early (around 7am) or just heading to the dining room; the lines were ALWAYS long and the time it took to get your food and be seated was equal to having a sit-down, made-to-order breakfast.  Seemed that everything in the dining room was the same fare as being served in the buffet.  We found the environment there to be more relaxing and less chaotic.

The ship itself is flashy and bold.  Princess and Royal Caribbean are a little more conservative in their decorating.  This was simply not important to us, but if I were decorating the ship I may have toned it down a bit.  The facilities: pools, hot tubs, etc.  were always clean and well maintained.  Main pool area was ALWAYS crowded with children, but this ship has the luxury of an adults-only atrium with a pool and 2 hot tubs where space always seemed to be adequate or better.  There was always extra space on the upper decks for sunbathing and relaxing.  The atrium is opened during the day so that the indoor area becomes an outdoor area.  The only thing that didn't make sense about this area was that the ICE CREAM MACHINE and BIG CHESS game were placed in this area!!  So, if you are looking to leave the "pitter patter of footsteps" at your threshold when you leave ....think again about getting full sanctity in this area.  What I did like was that when people would allow their children to get in these hot tubs, the Carnival staff was VERY attentive and enforced the adults only rule and politely asked the child to leave the hot tub or pool.  (Why people do this is beyond me!!- There is a children's area and a huge waterslide plus two pools in the main area for them.)  We were not travelling with children, and so I cannot comment on the Teen or childrens' areas onboard.  There appeared to be more than adequate facilities for children and families.

Some helpful (and money saving) tips:  If you are going to enjoy beverage services, do so while at sea.  You avoid tax this way, as tax is charged while in port.  Buckets of beer (Domestic-Bud, Bud lite-16 oz.) are available for $17.50 for 4.  You save over the beer by the bottle.  Coors light is the best deal for $13.50 per bucket, for 4; 12-oz. cans.  Get the "drink of the day" if you prefer cocktails, but instead of paying $6.75 for a souvenir glass, order it in a regular glass and you pay only $4.50.    A seven-day soda card is available for $44 at the beginning of the cruise.  Wait until you leave port and you will save tax on this purchase as well.  The staff is pretty diligent about "one drink" per card per trip to the bar, so it may be difficult or inconvenient to use one card for your whole party (as we have done with no problem on Royal Caribbean).  Gratuities:  You are charged a gratuity for room service whether you use it or not.  It also suggests in your daily paper that you tip room service stewards.  Hmmmm....seems like double tipping to me.  If I had it to do over again, I would have had the pursers desk remove my gratuities from the sail-n-sign card and would have presented the people who served us with cash.  I tipped a room service steward for a service I did not utilize, which takes tips away from the others who did serve us and served us well. 

Okay, now.....a word about the other guests on this ship:  And I am a well-travelled person who loves learning about other cultures.  It certainly was not ALL guests but there were an abundance of RUDE people on the ship.  I will not point to a specific culture as I would not want to be stereotyped by mine either.  There needs to be a little more order from the Carnival staff in this area, presently not their fault as they do what they are told to do.  Children would barrel into the elevator in front of a person in a wheelchair.  People were cutting in line, reaching over you to get food, demanding and entitled toward buffet servers (who very professionally smiled and did their very best to accommodate these folks despite their disgusting behavior)....there was loud noise in the hallway at night, people having no regard for those of us who were sleeping (and I'm tolerant up until midnight..)   This was not just a party crowd.  This was not just one family.  This was not just one individual.  There were an ABUNDANCE of people behaving in this manner.  Perhaps there is a cultural standard of which I am ignorant here.  But having travelled the world, I have never seen anything like this in my life from grown adults.  Please, thank you, and excuse me go a LONG LONG way toward happiness of all passengers.  Perhaps Carnival could place a staff member in the buffet area to remind people where lines begin and end.  The one time we called security about an obnoxiously loud party in one of the staterooms down the hall at 3 am, it was attended to promptly and adequately.

Overall, despite the aforementioned "cons"; this was a wonderful cruise experience.  Please be aware that this is an international cruise with passengers from everywhere in the world.  In comparison to past cruises, there were many more nationalities represented on this cruise than any other that I have experienced.  I would say that Americans comprised about 40-50% of the entire cruise population. This cruise also embarks/disembarks in Barbados as well as San Juan. So if you are willing to branch out a little culturally, this will be enriching.  If you're not, then this may not be the cruise for you. Less

Published 08/04/09

Cabin review: 4C2391 Interior

We were in 2391.  AVOID THIS CABIN AT ALL COST.  It is directly below the dining room.  It sounds like there's a bowling alley above you.

Read All Interior (4C) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

Went to the beach in Antigua, water not so clear as in St. Thomas but nice beach and atmosphere nonetheless. The shopping was SPECTACULAR~! Lots of jewelry stores and duty free shops!
Read 1191 Antigua Reviews

We rented a small car without doors called a "Moke"....if you are not experienced at driving on the left, don't do it. STreets are not well marked and you will spend most of your time (as did we) trying to figure out where the heck you are and how to get where you are going.
Read 1223 Barbados Reviews

Others on the cruise really enjoyed rainforest tour and Trafalgar falls. I would not recommend buying a shore excursion from anyone but Carnival. The downtown is flooded with gypsy taxis and shady characters, did not feel safe at all.
Read 669 Dominica Reviews

LOVED ST. KITTS!! Beware the strong british influence....there is NO CURSING on this island other than "Bloody" or "Damn"...anything else will result in a $500 fine!! We took a private tour through the "Tour store" (located to the left of the cruise dock) for $20 per person- half-island tour. This was about $40 per person purchased on board the ship. GREAT!! We got to go to a botanical garden overlooking the rainforest and see them make "Battique" a local method of dying fabric using wax. The tour guide was excellent, telling us history and interesting facts throughout the entire tour!
Read 1320 St. Kitts Reviews

We hired a private tour operator who showed us banana plantations and took us to many scenic overlooks for photo opportunities. While he did OK...I would recommend a more organized tour, you get what you pay for here. Also, we encountered a naked man (eww) relieving himself in the water as we were walking back to the ship!! I wouldn't swim near the cruise port! The markets were great and had the biggest cinnamon sticks I've ever seen! Buy some banana ketchup while you're there.
Read 1134 St. Lucia Reviews

Great beach experience! Clear waters, stiff drinks, AWESOME!! Took the skyride to paradise point, which is actually cheaper to purchase on the ship! Do it, you won't regret!! As for beach excursion, we went to Magens Bay, which cost $34 pp on the ship; we took a taxi for $8 pp each way and thne paid a $4 pp entry fee to the beach (the $4 is used for maintenance of the public beach area). The four of us went for very little more than half what it would cost on the ship. On the way to and from the beach, our driver gave us an island tour that lasted about 2 hours. He came back to get us exactly when he promised and didn't ask for payment until completely finished with the tour. Very professional!
Read 3995 St. Thomas Reviews

Compare Prices on Carnival Victory Southern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Victory cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Victory Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Victory Southern Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2009
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Victory deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Victory 71% Loved It

4 Day Western Caribbean Itiner
See all Carnival Victory Deals >>