We took at PH1. Never again. Will spend the extra couple of $ and book a PH2. There was some noise from the 12th deck, kitchen or something that was a bit annoying, but livable. Room was immaculate and room staff and butler super. Specialty restaurants are always great. We also love the Cafe, particularly sitting in the back--last night with sunset was beyond words. We never eat in the dining room. Loved Harvest Cay and I hope they keep the small resort in good order. We loved just chilling so much that we plan on doing it again next year--doesn't matter where we go. Agree with other comments about entertainment...Oceania is not known for its entertainment. That said the comedian/magician was GREAT. We don't book Oceania for its entertainment, we book it for where it goes, its service, its wonderful culinary school and its restaurants. I never give excellent on any reviews...and Oceania is about as good as it gets for the $.