We were on the June 20 repo cruise. Most of the reviewers have hit it on the head: the service on the ship is way below average and definitely below what should be expected for the amount of money you paid.
Going to dinner meant sitting for 3 hours, more if you went late and there wasn't a table. They were unorganized. The buffet's were incredibly crowded, the lines were long and there were few indoor seats.
The food was mediocre at best. If you like uncooked scrambled eggs, this is the place! The extra $10 per person is simply an additional charge. It is a sneaky underhanded way of getting more money without raising fares.