I will try to be positive but it's quite difficult. You just got the impression that P&O and the crew found this ship just a bit beyond their capabilities. You also feel Royal Caribbean would have had no such problems.
We have only cruised once before - two years ago on Navigator Of The Seas. A great ship, well run. But we liked the Baltic city itinerary and fancied being a bit "posher" with P&O (or so we thought).
So let's start with some positives:
Good middle-ish location. Quite a lot of engine noise but probably the same in all cabins.Good hanging space.Shower good.Excellent to have tea/coffeee in roon - filer coffee, refreshed each day. Also good size fridge.