The itinerary from NY to Quebec was excellent! Loved all the ports. Service and food were very good as well. The Caribbean Princess is currently drab, bland and boring in terms of decor and attitude. It not only needs major improvements in its appearance, but needs an overhaul in entertainment options and innovation, if it's going to serve generations in the coming years. We visited Newport, Boston, Bar Harbor, Saint John, Sydney, Halifax, Charlottetown, and Quebec. They were all interesting and the colors had changed by the time we got to Quebec at the beginning of Oct. I would definitely suggest this itinerary, just be aware that this is an old ship. I was onboard when it was new and contemporary. But times have changed and so has technology, without this ship changing with it. If you are aware of this, then your expectations will be appropriate for this itinerary during any fall season.