I have always sailed RCCL in the past - have done the Vision, Voyager, and Oasis class ships. Recently, I decided to sail NCL and choose the Pearl (Jewel class). I prefer this size ship and now am only sailing NCL due to butler/concierge in the suites. The mega ships are beautiful but due to size, I do not find enjoyable. I understand and I am amazed at the operation of the mega ships. On RCCL Allure: embarkation was very long process, long lines, and reservations were not available for shows or specialty dining. At times there were very long lines to enter the comp dining facilities so it was not the relaxing cruise experience I desired. Imagine moving 5,000+ passengers (amazing feat) but those same people that want to eat at the same time, travel elevators, see shows can be overwhelming...However, it is mitigated if you upgrade to suite level cabins. I have to say that if you are willing to splurge suites make the difference.

I sailed on NCL Pearl (Garden Villa) and it was a 5 star experience for me. The service was stellar. The ship is dated but it will get a refurbish soon. The complimentary dining was very good and the specialty restaurants were also very good. All staff we encountered were great and always had a smile. I also liked that there was not a photographer pressing constantly to take pictures. I find that annoying since we all have cameras today and they still charge a lot of money for pictures that we might buy if the prices came down a lot. I also enjoyed NCL free style cruising because some days I may want to eat early and some days late. I prefer to be more spontaneous and not tied to a dining schedule. I like the perks of a suite - priority embarkation/debarkation; daily snacks, personal requests, great dining reservations, assistance and guidance on shore excursions without waiting in lines to discuss. Left messages for concierge if busy and they followed up immediately. Celebrating birthday, anniversary, or special occasion? Your butler/concierge will make it special. We celebrated last minute birthday and they arranged all the food and decorations in the suite and that was such a special touch. They all made us feel special and welcomed and now I am hooked on the "suite life"!!! I have to say the ports were nice but I enjoy the aspect of cruising, dining, relaxing just as important. I never felt cramped on the ship and no overwhelming crowds. Many restaurants, bars, library, entertainment and decent fitness area to keep me busy. Just booked the same ship for 12 day trip in October.