We chose a cruise on the Pacific Jewel due to it going to the Conflict Islands.
Having been on 4 Carnival cruises, 2 on the Spirit and 2 on the Legend, we decided to give P & O a try despite reading many bad reviews.
The Waterfront dining room was excellent from the decor to the food and great service as well.
Great cabin with a great layout.
It is near the front end of the ship so you feel a far bit of movement and a little noisy when coming into a port due to the hydraulic pumps for the bow thrusters.
If we were to sail on the Pacific Jewel again we would look to get a cabin near the middle of the ship.