We have previously cruised with Seabourn (excellent, but expensive) and Silversea (not at all good and expensive) and we had also taken a cruise around the Caribbean with Celebrity which we thought offered the best value for money.
The Ship Reflection is excellent. Its new, clean, modern and spacious. No complaints at all with it.
The food quality is excellent across the board (perhaps not the Mast Grill....)
This Sky suite is well located centrally on deck 12 so handy for the lifts yet not close enough to be bothered by noise in the central atrium during the late evening music playing, or the pinging of the lifts. The cabin was spotlessly clean and serviced very efficiently each morning by two cleaning men who took care to note when we left the room and had it ready when we returned from breakfast each day.
One gripe is that the bath towels are tiny and Im quite small so it would be awful for bigger people
WORTH NOTING: if you like to rest in your room during the day, there is a lot of noise from the floor above. At first we thought there were 20 children running around in the cabin above, all day every day, but further investigation revealed that we were actually directly under the table tennis tables area of the pool deck!
This didnt really bother us as we didnt spend much of the day in the room, but it could really annoy some people who want to take an afternoon siesta