1. Home
  2. Cruise Reviews
  3. Emerald Star
We chose this as we had done the Mosel on a previous cruise (with another company) and wanted to include this on a variant itinerary, this tima ccompanied by friends. Our worst River cruise to date - with Emerald Waterways!!! (This was our 8th river cruise - so we know standards can be great) NEGATIVES: Bad cabin layout and lack of facilities (top deck level – in a so-called Grand Balcony Suite) Shortcomings included no mirror at all in the bedroom, tiny bathroom with no counter top, just a small hand basin; we had to walk sideways, crablike, between one side of the bed to get to the bathroom, despite acres of room between the window and balcony. Scarcely any long hanging space in the (very tiny) wardrobe, due to being occupied by an over-large bar fridge AND the safe. APPALLING DOCKING LOCATIONS - well outside of towns and the LAST WAS ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING, amid recycling centres with stagnant pools and consequent swarms of flies on board - on us and the food! Emerald is part of the Scenic Group ... but scenic it most certainly was NOT. Heaven knows what the next arrival group starting their cruise here will think! We have been to this town (TRIER) within a previous cruise company’s itinerary and we were then berthed at a most pleasant location within 10-15 minutes walking distance from the centre. The final insult was having to climb a very long gangplank, at about 30 degrees uphill, to reach our coach transport to the airport. Not only awful for us with hand luggage, but for the crew having to drag up our main cases. MENUS - very ‘average’ – apparently dictated by the parent company, leaving the head chef very little room for initiative, or to show personal flair. Also applies to the ‘entertainment’ such as it was, including a dreadful keyboard guy (who had no idea of what music would encourage those who wanted onto the dancefloor). Whilst most local guides were good there was one notable exception, who literally never stopped for a breath, just rattled on with a non-stop verbal barrage – I am sure that some of his information was of value, but was lost in the interminable lecture and anecdotes of his own experiences including family members. Many just lost all interest and several either drifted away from our group or switched off. Also he was supposed to be leading a gentle walking group, but started off on about 15 minutes continuous uphill route-march with no break or rest for those who needed it. POSITIVES: All the STAFF on the ship were excellent - THEY WERE GREAT - attentive and most helpful at all times ... just a shame that they were working for Emerald. Also the room keys (a new button-type) worked very well – best we have had so far. Several good LOCAL GUIDES. Good quality COACH transfers. Please see photos!

Our WORST river cruise to date (8th river cruise, so we know they can be great).

Emerald Star Cruise Review by BEARS 2

12 people found this helpful
Trip Details
We chose this as we had done the Mosel on a previous cruise (with another company) and wanted to include this on a variant itinerary, this tima ccompanied by friends.

Our worst River cruise to date - with Emerald Waterways!!!

(This was our 8th river cruise - so we know standards can be great)

NEGATIVES:

Bad cabin layout and lack of facilities (top deck level – in a so-called Grand Balcony Suite)

Shortcomings included no mirror at all in the bedroom, tiny bathroom with no counter top, just a small hand basin; we had to walk sideways, crablike, between one side of the bed to get to the bathroom, despite acres of room between the window and balcony. Scarcely any long hanging space in the (very tiny) wardrobe, due to being occupied by an over-large bar fridge AND the safe.

APPALLING DOCKING LOCATIONS - well outside of towns and the LAST WAS ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING, amid recycling centres with stagnant pools and consequent swarms of flies on board - on us and the food! Emerald is part of the Scenic Group ... but scenic it most certainly was NOT.

Heaven knows what the next arrival group starting their cruise here will think!

We have been to this town (TRIER) within a previous cruise company’s itinerary and we were then berthed at a most pleasant location within 10-15 minutes walking distance from the centre.

The final insult was having to climb a very long gangplank, at about 30 degrees uphill, to reach our coach transport to the airport.

Not only awful for us with hand luggage, but for the crew having to drag up our main cases.

MENUS - very ‘average’ – apparently dictated by the parent company, leaving the head chef very little room for initiative, or to show personal flair.

Also applies to the ‘entertainment’ such as it was, including a dreadful keyboard guy (who had no idea of what music would encourage those who wanted onto the dancefloor).

Whilst most local guides were good there was one notable exception, who literally never stopped for a breath, just rattled on with a non-stop verbal barrage – I am sure that some of his information was of value, but was lost in the interminable lecture and anecdotes of his own experiences including family members. Many just lost all interest and several either drifted away from our group or switched off. Also he was supposed to be leading a gentle walking group, but started off on about 15 minutes continuous uphill route-march with no break or rest for those who needed it.

POSITIVES:

All the STAFF on the ship were excellent - THEY WERE GREAT - attentive and most helpful at all times ... just a shame that they were working for Emerald. Also the room keys (a new button-type) worked very well – best we have had so far.

Several good LOCAL GUIDES. Good quality COACH transfers.

Please see photos!
BEARS 2’s Full Rating Summary
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Fitness & Recreation
Shore Excursions
Service
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get Emerald Star price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews