Reading another review about the state of the ship and the quality of the food, I'd like to share our experience onboard the Rotterdam. This was my fifth cruise on this ship.
We had dinner in the MDR 5 nights and breakfast every morning. Food was perfect, always right temperature and served promptly. Other guests at the table who did other cruiselines but were first time on HAL, commented postively on the quality compared to other ( 4 or 5 star) ships.
Dinner in the Pinnacle was top notch, we ate on the Lido once , also much to our liking.