Valentine and Birthday! We were on the Liberty in 2014 and loved it. We didn't plan on having the same cruise director but was an Awesome surprise! Love Corey Rogers!! First, embarkation is way too easy! Landed in SJU and was 15 min to ship and maybe 15 min till on ship...no line!! First, we loved every minute! Complaint - went by too fast! I thought all food and service in dining room was great! My biggest KUDOS is the casino bands! OMG they were awesome which if you are a casino person (I am) or if you like to hang on the Promenade then that's important So I read the other reviews and most seemed mad about the buffet ending early. I get it but this cruise is all about the ports! All ports except one day. Also we are not big buffet people so no big for us. The deli has delicious sandwiches and they are open after 3p. Shows were good. Room service great! Marriage show was absolutely hilarious! All service is wonderful. As far as I'm concerned, i'm not paying 2-3 grand more for RC or others. Small things other Carnival peeps might miss is they changed the party for past guests for platinum and diamond....also a BIG disappointment but really small thing is the Carnival chocolates at night. Its funny but my DH and DD were terminally sad. That's what chocolate will do to people! LOL! We are going for Platinum.