Having read these reviews extensively prior to taking this cruise, I really do think they say more about the reviewers than the cruises themselves.
For the price paid, I do think that this cruise represented outstanding value, and as such provided a really excellent experience.
For sure, the ship lacks the glamour and glitz of much younger sisters, so for example the bathroom was in poor condition and needed regrouting/modernising. But then the ship is perfectly comfortable, spotlessley clean, and has the advantage of a compactness and informality which allows for a very relaxed ambience and friendliness amongst both the staff and fellow passengers. I'm quite sure you could pay considerably more and find a cruise with uber gourmet food which would challenge the palate (and the wasteline/coronary arteries), but the quality of variety of the food in both restaurants/buffets was entirely adequate, and that's considering the fact that I'm a fussy eater. I always enjoyed my meals, it was plentiful and tasty, and the staff always obliging and keen to please their passengers' diets.
Rather tired looking, but very clean. If you go on holiday to spend a lot of time in your cabin, I'm not sure you should be on a cruise!