We couldn't have picked a better ship for our toddler's first cruise. I'll break this up into sections, but do keep in mind that it will be very kid-centric. :) (Keep in mind that I am not an experienced cruiser. This was my fourth cruise, with all previous cruises being on Carnival Freedom-class vessels.) Overall, there were minor hiccups here and there, but I don't get hung up on the little things when I'm on vacation.
SHIP
The ship is quite spectacular. Yes, it is large. Yes, there may be quite a bit of walking. However, the neighborhood concept is really wonderful. Royal does a great job of fragmenting the ship and overlapping activities to disperse the crowds. I know it was the offseason, but the only lines we encountered were embarking and at guest services the evening before debarkation. We thought the décor was lovely and enjoyed how each area had it's own personality.
We had a oceanview balcony, 7th floor Aft. Having been only in Carnival's delightfully orange/pink balcony rooms, the décor of the Oasis rooms seemed quite nice. We had the configuration with the bed by the closet, which I understand is less desirable, but I really liked it. It was nice to have some open floor space near the balcony where the kiddo could play.
I loved that you could move the small bedside tables and coffee table around the room. (One of ours stayed under the desk chair to save room. We also stashed our bag o' toys from the nursery under there.) I also loved that the couch was huge, as was the bed. My 6-4 hubby really appreciated these things. The other big win for RCI vs. Carnival is the sliding glass door. I love that you can keep it a little bit open if you want. I also love that it doesn't slam shut like the Carnival doors.
We thought there was a little more storage/closet space on Carnival. However, the little storage areas around the desk were really nice for small items.
The bathroom was comparable to Carnival in size, but the décor was nicer. I also liked the tube showers better, partly because of the bar for shaving your legs. It was super easy to give the toddler a shower without drenching myself. I wish there was a laundry line like on Carnival, but it's a minor want.
The room showed a little wear (a stain on the carpet, wear on the couch and desk, etc.), but nothing major. We actually thought the common areas of the ship were in very nice shape for a ship set to go into dry dock.
The 7th floor was a great location for us, since we loved the Boardwalk so much. It was also only a floor away from Central Park. We did not feel much movement, despite being in the aft portion of the ship.
Easy embarkation and debarkation. Hotels and airport very close by.
Very nice, easy beach day for free.
The port area is ok. It's basically the same as any other port area.
The park had a wide variety of activities and areas. The park was very clean and the staff quite friendly.