This was our first clothing optional cruise, but definitely not our last. The boat was full of nothing but cheerful people. I guess it's hard to be crabby when your not wearing pants! This was truly a clothing OPTIONAL cruise. Most folks chose to take full advantage of the sun and ocean breezes, but some preferred full or partial covering and that was OK. I can't recommend the Bare Necessities folks and organization highly enough. there were 16 first time couples, and we all said we'd come back in a heartbeat.
The ship, meanwhile is great. When the wind blew the Captain shut off the engine and hoisted all 42 sails. Stunning! There isn't much choice of activities on this 200+ passenger ship, but all we wanted to do was lounge around on deck, with occasional (and voluntary) sail hoisting and mast climbing.
One day he raised all the sails in a very light breeze, and launched two tenders full of photographers to circle the ship. She is a BEAUTIFUL ship!
There is a minuscule library, comprised solely of donated books in many different languages. And the entertainment is very low key.
Shoe excursions were very reasonably priced, with a good variety.
The cabin is small, but all we did there was sleep, so it was quite sufficient. Minimal closet and drawer space, but on this cruise there were no formal nights, so it was adequate. No bathtub and small shower, but adequate.