Highs - Specialty restaurants (Cagney's, LeBistro), ship's facilities (layout, common areas), great staff, nice photos (expensive though)
Lows - Casino was smokey, machines were tight, blackjack games were stacked in the ships favor. Free food choices like the buffet and main dinning room were just ok, room was above the ultra lounge disco (8634) had to move (boom, boom, boom), docks always seems farther away than other lines (Holland America, Princess) which meant lots of walking.
Entertainment was good, comedian was first class. Liked the string trio onboard. Legends show was decent, ship's dance and singers were very good. Cabin was fine and well maintained. Was traveling with older parents, think this was a good fit.
Right above the Ultra Lounge, disco was booming all night, not good for light sleepers.