• Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Log In
Celebrity Reflection Cruise Review
5.0 / 5.0
Cruise Critic Editor Rating
1,874 Reviews

Very Disappointed

Celebrity Reflection Cruise Review by HOFFMEISTER

1 people found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: May 2015
  • Destination: the Eastern Mediterranean
  • Cabin Type: Deluxe Ocean View with Verandah 2C

Having travelled on RCI Independence of the Seas 7 years ago, (which was fantastic) this was our second cruise and one which we were very excited about. However, from the moment we stepped on board I knew we had made a huge mistake. Where the RCI Indy had literally blown us away as we boarded, this ship totally lacked luster with its dark panelled walls, no bright central arena, just a dark central staircase with net curtains hanging down either side. Depressing. However, given our initial reaction we were pleasantly surprised by the cabin. We had opted for one that was assigned by Celebrity and were assigned 6301 at the aft of the ship, directly over the "Blu" restaurant. It was very nicely decorated with light wood units, a deeper than average balcony and a superb shower room. Absolutely no faults there at all. Sadly that was the best bit of the whole cruise.

We ate in the Oceanview cafe for nearly every meal as my husband's feet had swelled badly and he could not wear shoes, so we were unable to use the Opus dining room as they enforce a dress code (which we fully applaud). The food was always cold - and I mean often stone cold. We did complain but they only expressed surprise and nothing changed. The plates are also cold, and the food stations illogically set out so people have to keep chopping around to make up the meal they would like, so its chaos when its busy. Also the loud screeching female singer they seem to have permanently as background music is truly dreadful.

As for entertainment: the theatre shows were excellent, different every night and of a high standard. The other entertainment in bars was also good in the main, apart from the female rock/pop singer in the central area who was often off-key. Other than that, there is none. Therefore, its a boring ship. High price shops, high price photos ($25 per copy), extortionate cover charges for speciality restaurants ($45 per head) which were usually empty. Beware of staff dressed as waiters coming to talk to you while you eat in the Ocean cafe, or drink in a bar, as after a few minutes they then launch into the sales pitch for a particular restaurant. This ship is ideal for those who wish to sunbathe by day and drink by night. There is no decent dance floor and no fun activities like mini-golf such as on RCI. The indoor pool closes 2 hours BEFORE the outdoor one. The library is poorly stocked and not quiet at all, totally open to the sounds from the rock singer below.

As for the lawn on the top deck, this is a total waste of space, offering cabanas for the few who wish to pay $145 for the pleasure of sitting on a wicker chair/sunbed under a piece of canvas on a sea day. Its a bargain (not) at just $95 for a port day! And the port excursions are expensive, you can do better deals on shore locally. Celebrity seem to be about taking you to ports where you will need to take the excursions to enjoy it, two of which are Athens and Naples. At Athens you are left to walk approximately 1.5 miles to the town via a very busy highway. As for Naples, its dirty and not worth the visit, so take a boat from the port quayside to Capri for the day. The best place was Rhodes, followed by Mykonos. Santorini was OK, but with 2 huge cruise ships in port together, and the only was in was by tender and then cable car (unless you want to walk up 500 steps behind a poor overworked donkey) the place was heaving.

The shops on board are expensive, "named" brand merchants, and only one that sold just a very few ordinary items that might be of need such as toiletries. There are various bazaar sales, but they are the same tourist items that you just saw in your last port, and not at the same price. All in all, this ship is about taking money off you as much as it can. On the plus side, the staff are all absolutely delightful, very polite and friendly. However, we will definitely not book with Celebrity again and return to normal prices and some fun on RCI.

HOFFMEISTER's Full Rating Summary
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Public Rooms
Fitness & Recreation
Sign Up for Price Drop Alerts
Get tomorrow's price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Cabin Review

Deluxe Ocean View with Verandah 2C
Cabin 2C 6301

The cabin was excellent with a larger than average balcony and had a lovely shower room. This was the best bit of the cruise.

Port & Shore Excursion Reviews

Taormina (Messina)

Worth a stroll around, some nice street cafes and shops. There are a couple of local bus tours you can take which will go around the town if you don't fancy walking. Plenty of vendors and taxi offers as you leave the ship!


Best bit, the main seafront and marina. Worth the walk. Worst bit, as you leave the ship you will enter the bazaar shopping area, where you will be continually bombarded by the shopkeepers and street sellers - it is utterly exhausting saying "no". They will even run along beside you.


Totally fabulous. The market area as you leave the ship in the old town is amazing and a total delight. If you continue through it you will also reach a lovely shaded park and then the glitzy shops. But the market is huge and simply lovely - and NO pressure!


Its truly lovely. However we were one of 2 huge cruise ships in port, so lines for the cable car were very long and the very narrow alleys completely overwhelmed by us tourists. But its still worth the effort.

Athens (Piraeus)

Its a port town, nothing more, nothing less. A taxi to Athens Plaka cost EUR23. We took the Metro back for EUR 1.20. But the walk from/to the port is long, no coaches - unless you are mobility restricted. So take a taxi - plenty just outside the cruise terminal.


Naples itself is dirty and noisy. Take a trip somewhere else like Capri. You can walk through the cruise terminal (which has some nice shops) to the quayside where the ferries depart. It was about EUR32 return on the fast ferry to Capri - but get there asap after you dock to catch the fast boat.


Beautiful tranquil place, whitewashed buildings and narrow streets and alleyways. Truly picturesque. Easy to walk around and shop keepers were very friendly. Loved it.

Previous ReviewNext Review
10 Reviews Written
50 Helpful Votes
Never Miss a Deal!
Subscribe and Save
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

More Celebrity Reflection Reviews

Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.