Where's the spirit on the Spirit?: Carnival Spirit Cruise Review by dellyb

Carnival Spirit 4
Member Since 2006
15 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

Where's the spirit on the Spirit?

Sail Date: December 2008
Destination: Mexican Riviera
Embarkation: San Diego
Background: We have been on 10 other cruises, mostly in the Caribbean. We have cruised on NCL, RCCL, Princess, and Celebrity before this Carnival cruise. We have come to expect a certain tone and level of activity on board ships, with which to compare our recent Carnival experience. We found our cruise lacking in almost every category except for shore activities, which we arranged for ourselves.

Flight Info: We flew from Bellingham, WA, to San Diego on Allegiant Airlines. That turned out to be a lucky break for us, as the day we left (12-21-08) Sea-Tac was snowed in and many flights were cancelled. We spoke to many people on the ship who said that friends and family members missed the cruise because they couldn't get out. One man said he flew his wife to meet the ship in Acapulco to the tune of over $1000 US. Bellingham is about 80 miles north of Seattle, and we had a few empty seats on our flight down. Something to keep in mind if the weather outside is frightful in the More northwest. On the return, San Diego was fogged in and our outbound flight was cancelled due to weather. We left the next morning after staying at the Sheraton at our expense.

Hotel Info: We stayed in SD on the cheap, at the Dolphin Inn (http://www.dolphin-motel.com/bry/dolphin/home.html), across from the San Diego sports fishing dock where the charter boats moor. Our bare-bones, small room was $66 a night, which included a continental breakfast. The place was really cute and the staff was very helpful. When we had difficulty finding a van-sized cab to take us four miles to the ship, the owner and his son loaded our luggage and us onto their private cars and drove us there. They wouldn't accept a tip for the service. We will always be grateful and will stay there again. By staying there, we were also treated to the sight of a returning sports fishing charter boat that returned from Mexican waters with about 200 yellow fin tuna and wahoo, including 61 tuna over 200 pounds each. That was something to see!

Embarkation: Excellent. It was POURING rain in San Diego (This coming from people who live north of Seattle), and we were drenched when we arrived to embark. The process was extremely smooth. Staff provided us with extra bag tags, as the rain had soaked through ours and they were falling off. We dried off on a big tour boat next to the ship, and were ushered quickly through the arrival process and onto the ship. Surprisingly smooth.

Ship Info: The Spirit seemed like an older ship, though it was launched in 2001. It had everything our other cruises had, except for much spirit, oddly enough. I guess we would have to say it was adequate, which was a bit of a disappointment. We like a good bar at night for instance, so were disappointed to learn that the funnest bars were the crew bar, which we couldn't get to, and the Karaoke bar. The stewards, waiters, and other staff were very nice, but there was no cohesive spirit of fun. We had been expecting a "fun ship," and couldn't find fun on board. Celebrity has martini bars with flair; most ships have live bands that play on the pool deck, creating a lively atmosphere; Celebrity usually has quartets that play around the ship. Carnival Spirit had a couple older guys perched on stands above a bar in the center of the lobby and above the casino bar, playing electric guitars and singing solo. Strange, and seemingly cheap.

Stateroom: We had a standard inside cabin which was fine. Our steward Lito did a great job, with towel animals every night and excellent service. The only weird thing about the cabin was that you had to swipe a personal card through a reader on the safe to open and close it. While this was safer than using a room card, it wasn't as safe as a combination keypad, as you needed to keep another card out of the safe to get into the safe. If people used a credit card, they couldn't leave it in the safe, where it would be safe.

Dining: Great staff, adequate food. This was the first cruise we have been on where most nights I didn't find an item on the menu that I really wanted for dinner. One time pasta was cold, one time a flat iron steak was rubbery, and most times the food was good but not great. Breakfast in the dining room was a tad lacking. They had a butter substitute on the tables, for instance, rather than butter. Out of the four days we breakfasted in the dining room, they only presented the pastry basket once. At dinner, no bread basket on the table; they would come by at the beginning and serve a roll or two. And no breadsticks, which we loved on Celebrity. These are picky little things and we probably sound like snobs, but it was the little things that differentiated this cruise from all the others. Excellent Warm Melting Chocolate Cake and Bitter and Blanc. The highlight of dining was the Supper Club, where the service was fantastic, only surpassed by the high cuisine. The Lobster Bisque was one of the finest tastes I've every experienced. Ashlie Dias, the Executive Chef, was a master, and a really nice guy.

Activities: If you love trivia, you'll love this cruise. Our itinerary included four days at sea, and we checked every day for the activities. Mostly it was trivia, it seemed. There was a waterslide on board, which was open only two days out of seven. We found it open on Christmas, and had a blast going down it over and over as we pulled into Acapulco. It was open on the second sea day also. Lots of fun if you lay down in a luge position. If you see the slide open, take advantage of it as it might not be open again. There were no educational activities on board. Less

Published 01/03/09

Cabin review: 4D Interior

Read All Interior (4D) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

We toured on our own with Pink Lady Tours, specifically with Olga Escuen, who was an absolute dream of a tour guide. Please contact her at oescuen@hotmail.com, or pinkladyolga-aca@hotmail.com. Her cell number is 044 (744)44 19 62 36. She picked us up just outside the dock in an airconditioned Suburban, and took us to the cliff divers first. We got there early and had great spots for the divers. Then we were off to a market for 20 minutes, and then to a couple of great scenic spots on the opposite end, clear up on top. She provided great historic and specific info about all the sights in between. I overheard another tour's passenger asking about the architect of a church we toured, and their guide didn't know info Olga had already told us. We felt lucky and special to have her. $35 a person for five hours - private tour.

Read 204 Acapulco Reviews

Zihuatanejo was the best part of our trip, and the place we felt most relaxed. We suggest you take a private water taxi to Las Gatos beach for $10 apiece, rather than waiting for an hour for the cheaper one at $3.50. It was high season when we were there, so it was crowded on the taxis. Had we known the hassle and the wait, we would have forked over the extra money for a quick trip. We hooked up with Franko for beach chairs and buckets of Corona for $1.50 each, and a decent lunch. Ended the day with Margaritas which were really, really strong. A perfect, relaxing beach day in the sun in a laid back part of a laid back town.

Actually MANZANILLO, which isn't on the dropdown list. We took a cab ($12 for four) to Santiago where we went ATV four-wheeling for about 4 hours through Jiovanis Tours (avalos_nueva@hotmail.com, 314-119-2682). The place the cab drops you off is a roadside hut, but the ATVs are in great shape and the tour of the back country fields, woods, rivers, and towns is fantastic. Bring water and prepare to come back totally dusty. This was really, really fun and worth the money. Again, we booked it separately for $70 apiece, as compared to a group of 20 as a ship-arranged shore excursion for $139 each. We got to go fast and didn't have to wait for the group.

Read more Carnival Spirit cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Spirit Review >>
Member Since 2006
15 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?