Overall A Good Cruise, Except One Thing...: Carnival Liberty Cruise Review by papasprep

Carnival Liberty 4
Member Since 2012
34 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

Overall A Good Cruise, Except One Thing...

Sail Date: March 2015
Destination: Southern Caribbean
Embarkation: San Juan
This was our first Carnival cruise. Overall, it compared well with the other cruise lines we have sailed with. The cabin and shower seemed a bit larger than other standard cabins on other lines. Makes a big difference. The food was consistently good, both in the dining room and on Lido deck. Plenty of variety. Service was also very good. Wait staff, cabin steward and other staff we encountered, were eager to please. They don't hover, but are always nearby. Didn't find there was much to do that was of interest on sea days, but that was fine with us. Also seems to be a bit less information, but there is also less pushing of the casino, so I was good with that. The one issue was noise while trying to sleep. We were on deck 2. Every night, there was those walking through the hallways in the berthing areas at 1-3am, speaking loudly in Spanish as they came through. When we spoke to the staff about this, they were concerned, and told us to call security, but that would be of no value as More those making merry would be gone by the time they got there, on all but one night. We have taken cruises with other lines out of Puerto Rico and always on lower decks, and never had an issue til we sailed with Carnival. There should be signs or an announcement made early in the cruise to be quiet in the berthing areas. I suggested this and the lady at guest services said she would suggest it. I would definitely take Carnival again, but never again out of Puerto Rico.

One other note. We sailed over Good Friday. While they had posted LGBT gatherings every night, not one word or service was offered for Good Friday. Shame on Carnival. Less

Published 04/10/15

Cabin review: Outside2238

We had an outside cabin. Loved the window. It was wide enough you could sit up next to it. Bed was situated to the side of window which I liked. Room was larger than other standard cabins on other lines. Shower also seemed a bit bigger. Overall pleased with room. Two negatives. It's at the front of the ship. So when front of the ship rises up and falls on waves, it can wake a light sleeper, which I am. Also this cruise on Carnival out of Puerto Rico had people speaking loudly in Spanish in the early morning hours, waking even my hard-to-wake husband. Never has happened on other cruise lines.

Port and Shore Excursions

Agapey Chocolate Factory Tour

Booked this directly with the owner online. The Owner sent excellent directions after we booked the tour. It was only about a 10-15 minute walk from the ship, but beware, many seem to get lost, perhaps because they do not pay careful attention to the directions?? If you take a left at the very first traffic circle right outside the gate for the shipyard,then another left at the roads end, you will see the sign for Agapeys on your left. If you get lost, ask a bus driver where the old Colgate bldg is. Agapey is in the back of that bldg. Anyway, tour, which is all in one room is educational and interesting. Tried the different beans, sugars and final products, and learned a lot about chocolate making from the owner. He explains the process and shows you the machines he uses and how they work. Bring cash if you want to buy chocolate at tours end. Great tour!

Historic Site

We toured Hassel Island with Doc, which we arranged prior to the cruise by calling the St Thomas Historical Trust. The number is online. We met in Frenchtown, where we met Doc and were taken over to the Island. Doc was informative and entertaining as walked and stopped at various stops. Although it was over a 3 mile walk, it didn't seem that long. Doc checked with us often as we walked along with frequent stops. There are some steep inclines and lots of sun, so you need sun screen and good walking shoes and the ability to walk well. That said we had a couple in their 70s and they did well. Doc was a wealth of historical information and we really enjoyed the tour. Cost was a $50 donation to the Trust.

Compare Prices on Carnival Liberty Southern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Liberty cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Liberty Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Liberty Southern Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2012
34 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Skip X

See Carnival Liberty deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
Carnival Liberty 76% Loved It

4 Day Bahamas Itinerary
See all Carnival Liberty Deals >>