We actually did a back to back for our first cruise. We went to the western Caribbean first. We enjoyed Labadee which was our first port. The only complaint would be the people begging you to buy their stuff. Cozumel , Cayman islands and Falmouth , Jamacian were great and the weather was perfect. We only had to use the tender twice in the 2 weeks we were on the ship.
The food in the dining room was great with the exception of the rolls. They were so tough to eat that I stopped trying to eat them. Our waiter was Amit and his asst. was Ismail they were the best you could ask for. The food in the Windjammer was a disappointment to me. I thought the gravy tasted like cinnamon and the biscuits were a lot like cornbread. I had watched some you tube videos before the cruise so my expectations were high. I only ate bacon for breakfast and the biggest part of the time I had to ask them to cook it crisp. I drink unsweet tea and that wasn't good either. I ended up having to drink water at every meal which wasn't really a bad thing. I did love the salad bar.
I was afraid I would gain some weight while on the cruise. I actually lost some weight. I think a lot of this was the walking around that we did which was good for us. The shows were good and enjoyable.
Our cabin steward was great the cabins were nice. The only downside was the refrigerator. It never really got cold. This must be normal because they had it packed with candy and soft drinks and chips. We had them remove this stuff because the prices were out of site. We wanted to use it for water but the water from the faucet was colder then what we got from the refrigerator.