I was really hoping to recreate the magic of being aboard the Solstice five years ago, however, this voyage had the flavor of a completely opposite experience.
The ship itself is great. I found it to be relatively clean and I loved that it was decorated for the holiday. Celebrity always has amazing looking ships. The re-done Sunset Bar is beautiful and probably the finest bar on board the ship.
Did not have all the amenities of a Concierge class cabin in the room when I arrived. Had to ask. Housekeeping never folded my clothes when they laid on the sofa (not that they needed folding, but they did on the last trip!) Stateroom attendants seemed new to the ship, not very well trained.
Came in at 3:30PM -- would have been nicer to make it a morning port-of-call and leave in the evening, instead of 10PM. Did my own walking tour, it was awesome.
Nice little touristy shopping mall in St. Maarten if that's your thing, but really hard to get away from that area if it's not (and it isn't mine). That left little time to explore the rest of the island, which isn't easy to get around. Port workers were not helpful with directions to other areas of the island.