For starters, the ship needs a facelift. it's rusty in some areas, my bathroom had mold and a broken tile. The food was not quite up to par, no more chocolates in the evening, except for one night. It seems like they are cutting corners everywhere you look. We paid for the airport to cruise transportation and i had to go all over to find the representative. If I were older, I would have had a hard time walking so much. They also didn't have a step stool to get on or off the shuttle buses. The shore excursions were pretty good. I had no complaints, except that maybe the Manhattan one could have been a little longer. three and one half hours did not do justice. The entertainment was pretty good, they had four afternoon matinees, which were pretty nice. The in room movies were outrageous in price. The Silhouette has free in room movies plus paid ones, this one only paid movies and they were either $12.95 or $14.95. A bit much. The Canada ports all had WIFI and were covered, Portland and Bar Harbor were open and those were the two ports were it rained. I realize that this is not Celebrity's fault but they might help in doing something about it. The disembarkation was extra long. I don't know if that was New York's fault or the ship's, but we were in back of the dining room and never heard any announcements, just wait, wait wait. there could have been coffee and pastries while waiting. I loved the itinerary but was quite disappointed with the ship. I don't think I would recommend this trip on this particular ship.