Reflections on the Reflection- E Caribbean~ 3/2014: Celebrity Reflection Cruise Review by autigerinnc

Celebrity Reflection 5
Member Since 2005
63 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

Reflections on the Reflection- E Caribbean~ 3/2014

Sail Date: March 2014
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami
First, we've cruised Carnival, Royal Caribbean, HAL, and Princess. The Reflection was certainly the prettiest and classiest ship we've enjoyed in our 13 different cruises. I call it understated elegance, and loved the ambiance it provided. It is full of intimate places to sit and relax, all beautiful and well designed. The ship is immaculately clean, as are the cabins. The cruisers ranged from 30-80, I'd guess, with most in the 40-50 range. It was not a really old crowd at all like HAL, but also there were few children in March, which was nice. It was a different experience than other cruises, and it's hard to explain. It wasn't a riotous good time like Carnival, it didn't have lots of physical options like Royal Caribbean (zip lines, flow riders, etc.), but it did have excellent evening entertainment in the form of production shows and headliners, a beautiful adult only pool solarium, outstanding food, interesting seminars and classes (the only Apple seminars at sea), and exemplary More employees and service. There is an art studio, five or more specialty restaurants, a lovely coffee/pastry bar, 14 bars and nightclubs, a place for movies, a huge internet iLounge, amazing art as decor, great spa services (including a fantastic acupuncturist), and plenty of chaise lounges around the pools. The buffet dining room, the Oceanview Cafe, was quite good with excellent variety. It seemed that the children's and teen's areas were well designed and appreciated. The bathrooms in the cabins were larger than usual and better designed--love the solid shower doors. We had the classic drink package, which was a real plus for us, as we got cappuccinos and lattes, as well as soft drinks, beer, wine, and cocktails. Many cruisers told me that they have sailed this ship several times, even though the itineraries were the same, just because they enjoyed so much. I normally don't want to sail the same ship twice, but this one I would. It's a huge ship, but didn't seem that way at all. Great design. Embarkation and debarkation were excellent.

My criticisms:

~the entertainment/bands/vocalists in the various lounges weren't all that good

~the variety of food in the main dining room seemed limited to me

~the art studio should be expanded

~not enough opportunities for dancing to the "oldies"--60s, 70s, and even 80s. One nightclub dedicated to that several nights a week would be quite popular, I would think, judging from the passengers. Most of us have our old standbys that we look forward to on a cruise….silly things like The Village People and YMCA, line dancing to The Electric Slide, and so on. Silly things, I know, but the crowd always enjoys them and participates.

~most of the dances, parties, etc., were on the pool deck late at night. I think many people enjoy those, but would also enjoy some of them being indoors in nicer surroundings.

So, those are our impressions It was for us the most relaxing cruise we've ever taken. It wasn't "fun", as much as lovely and relaxing. It was what we needed. However, for families with children, I think Carnival or Royal Caribbean would be a much better choice. Less

Published 04/07/14

Cabin review: 1081

We liked the Sky Deck because it had cabins above and below. It was a quiet deck, although the entry doors to all cabins are in pairs, so that when the cabin next door slams their door, it shakes your cabin. It's that way on all decks. In Concierge Class, we had fresh flowers and fruit daily, afternoon canapés, and two room stewards. The cabin was no larger than a verandah, though, so I don't feel it was worth the extra $$. I might consider Aqua Class, even though the cabin is still the same size, because you get to eat in your own private restaurant, Blu. The MDR is lovely, but anytime dining is relegated to the upper floor and is rather plain.

Port and Shore Excursions

We wanted to see the French side, so we took a local bus to Marigot. It was a real disappointment. I expected it to be quaint and very French, but it wasn't. It was still poor and run down. We had a decent lunch at the Marina at La Belle Epoch, but it wasn't special at all. The Dutch side at Phillipsburg had been "redone" since we were there last, and if you like shopping, you could stay busy for several hours. I've heard the beaches are gorgeous, but it was really disappointing to see people swimming right by the water taxi pier--crowded, narrow beach with no amenities. Stay away from that one! Phillipsburg was prettier than many of the other port towns.

St. John Tour

St John is well worth visiting..the beaches are empty and the prettiest anywhere. We would have liked more time in town to shop, but other than that, the tour was great.

Compare Prices on Celebrity Reflection Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Celebrity Reflection cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Celebrity Reflection Review >>

Compare Prices on Celebrity Reflection Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2005
63 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Skip X

See Celebrity Reflection deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
Celebrity Reflection 83% Loved It

14 Night Western Europe Transatlantic
See all Celebrity Reflection Deals >>