GENERAL: We are in our 50s and have sailed with HAL three times previously. We always feel like the "kids" onboard, since almost everyone is retired. The music and entertainment are geared to a generation older than we are, but we know that in advance. My parents who sailed with us (in their late 70s) fit right in.

We were looking for a relaxing, less expensive cruise that we could enjoy without spending lots of money on shore excursions. We did not buy any shore excursions and did just fine. We also wanted to see fall colors, and we did see some, though not at the peak.

CABIN AND SHIP FACILITIES: Our standard oceanview cabin was very comfortable, with plenty of storage space and the nice extra of a makeup mirror. The shower head worked well, though the water temperature varied somewhat. The room was well lit with good bed and furniture. It was kept immaculately clean by our steward. Nights were very quiet. Our only complaint was that our smoke alarm went off in the middle of the night for no apparent reason. Someone had to come and take it down to be replaced. Read more