1. Home
  2. Cruise Reviews
  3. Carnival Magic
This was our third Magic cruise, but our first as Platinum. We always drive in from Houston the same morning, and park with Lighthouse which we book online. Were able to embark and go directly to our rooms at 11:15, and especially enjoyed the special lines at the service desk for Platinum members as well as the chocolate treats that appeared in our room. Service in all areas was great and very friendly, as always. James, the cruise director was very enthusiastic and entertaining, as was Jay (karaoke). Loved, loved the Indian food at the back of the ship, as well as the deli, pizza, salad bar and mid-ship BBQ on sea days. Shows were only OK, except for the Illusion show which was great. Cove balcony and Anytime Dining were perfect for us (only wait time was on first formal night and then it was only 15 minutes). Room 2325 - cove balcony. Had a whining noise that kept us awake two nights. We were told it was because the stabilizers were out, and had a very hard time sleeping those two nights. Have had cove balconies before without this issue, so will try again as we love the privacy and shade of the coves. We never do ship excursions, but prefer to go out on our own. Loved all three ports and never felt in danger. One small improvement could be food service when returning from ports - it seemed they were on a skeleton crew and lines were very slow. Next time we may try room service when first returning to the ship. Brunch in the dining room was very good (how can you beat filet mignon and eggs, or mushroom pasta?), and the family comedy was entertaining. All in all a great cruise!  

The Magic is magic again!

Carnival Magic Cruise Review by cwb34

Trip Details
This was our third Magic cruise, but our first as Platinum. We always drive in from Houston the same morning, and park with Lighthouse which we book online. Were able to embark and go directly to our rooms at 11:15, and especially enjoyed the special lines at the service desk for Platinum members as well as the chocolate treats that appeared in our room.
Service in all areas was great and very friendly, as always. James, the cruise director was very enthusiastic and entertaining, as was Jay (karaoke). Loved, loved the Indian food at the back of the ship, as well as the deli, pizza, salad bar and mid-ship BBQ on sea days. Shows were only OK, except for the Illusion show which was great. Cove balcony and Anytime Dining were perfect for us (only wait time was on first formal night and then it was only 15 minutes).
Room 2325 - cove balcony. Had a whining noise that kept us awake two nights. We were told it was because the stabilizers were out, and had a very hard time sleeping those two nights. Have had cove balconies before without this issue, so will try again as we love the privacy and shade of the coves.
We never do ship excursions, but prefer to go out on our own. Loved all three ports and never felt in danger. One small improvement could be food service when returning from ports - it seemed they were on a skeleton crew and lines were very slow. Next time we may try room service when first returning to the ship. Brunch in the dining room was very good (how can you beat filet mignon and eggs, or mushroom pasta?), and the family comedy was entertaining. All in all a great cruise!
 
cwb34’s Full Rating Summary
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Cabin
Fitness & Recreation
Service
Free Price Drop Alerts
Get Carnival Magic price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email

Cabin Review

Cove Balcony
Cabin 7C 2325
Room 2325 - cove balcony. Had a whining noise that kept us awake two nights. We were told it was because the stabilizers were out, and had a very hard time sleeping those two nights. Have had cove balconies before without this issue, so will try again as we love the privacy and shade of the coves.
Deck 2 Inside Cabins, Outside Cabins, Balcony Cabins