This was the first time we've taken a family reunion cruise. There were nine of us, three siblings, their spouses and two adult children, one with significant other. Five of the group had never been on a cruise ship. I basically organized the group and our choice of itinerary was based on hubby & brothers desire to scuba dive together in the Caribbean.
Besides itinerary this cruise was chosen for affordability and the newness of the Miracle. I had seen photos of the wild decor and felt like we needed to be on a "fun ship" for our family cruise. Carnival did not disappoint. I noticed significant improvements since our last cruise on Carnival five years ago.
Carnival has toned down the constant announcements over their public address system - these are not broadcast in public areas only. They were not so "in your face" about playing bingo or having your picture taken. I do think that Carnival has the best photographers over other cruise lines. The crew was friendly, the dining room service (at least at our table) was excellent.