Having cruised extensively with different lines, I found that this cruise was fantastic. The Windjammer was a zoo on embarkation, but that has been my experience on any cruise that I haven't been in the first group of people to get onboard.
The Voyager was the nicest ship I've been on, not by far, but just for what is offered onboard, not that I did everything available, but I was glad the option was there.
We did have great weather for November in an Atlantic crossing! That was one thing I was worried about. We had an aft balcony (8390 - if anybody gets the chance, BOOK IT!) and I wondered if we'd get any use out of it on the sea days, but we used it every day, even on Thursday until the rain started.