Disapponted a little with Celebrity this time.: Celebrity Reflection Cruise Review by vgc8260

Celebrity Reflection 4
Member Since 2013

Overall Member Rating

Disapponted a little with Celebrity this time.

Sail Date: December 2012
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami
I booked a cruise on the Celebrity Silhouette in December of 2011 for a 7 night Western Caribbean cruise for December/12. As soon as the cruise was booked, I then booked the accommodations(3 full days in advance of the cruise),a car rental and airfare in Fort Lauderdale due to the ship being scheduled to depart out of Port Everglades.

A little more than three months after booking, I received an email from the travel agent advising that my cruise had been cancelled due to a charter. The travel agent, who was representing Celebrity, advised that I had three options.

Option 1

Cancel the cruise with Celebrity

Option 2

Select from 4 cruises that were departing on January

Option 3

Sail on the new ship Celebrity Reflection.

Being that the airfare was booked on points and there were no more available flights out of either Fort Lauderdale or Miami and our points were non refundable, I did not really have a choice. Hindsight More being 20/20,I should have cancelled with Celebrity and sailed on the Ruby Princess that was sailing out of Port Everglades the same day that the Silhouette was scheduled to depart.

To be fair to Celebrity, the Reflection is a beautiful ship both inside and out. The room that I had booked on the Silhouette was also granted to me and was even bigger that the same room that I had when I sailed on the Solstice in 2010.

I need to point this out for anyone who is planning to sail with Celebrity or any other cruise line for that matter. DO NOT book your shore excursions until you are on the ship! I had booked mine two month prior to boarding the ship. The two excursions I booked were for Puerto Rico (I had never been to) and St Maarten (also had never been to). Upon entering into my stateroom for the first time, there was an envelope with the shore excursion tickets as promised and a ticket stub showing the purchase of the two and also the departing times.

Where my first problem began was when I opened up the envelope. The St Maarten tickets were there but there were no signs of Puerto Rico. I advised my stateroom attendant about the missing tickets and was advised not to worry that he would look after it. It was not until we were on the first day at sea (the day before Puerto Rico) that there was an announcement that our expected time of arrival in Puerto Rico was at 5:00pm.We actually arrived at 4:00pm. My shore excursion receipt showed that the excursion was scheduled to leave at 3:00pm. Up until I left from home (five days before the Puerto Rico excursion), there was never any notice that there was a change in the arrival time in Puerto Rico ... even on the trip summary that I printed out. The trip summary still showed the Puerto Rico excursion departing at 3:00pm. It was for this port that I decided to stay with the Celebrity cruise instead of going to the Ruby Princess.

Upon checking our stateroom TV for our up to date credits, I noticed that instead of issuing a credit to my credit card that I paid with a few months earlier, Celebrity had deposited the money into our on board account (I was not impressed). I went down to the front desk of the ship and advised that there was no way that they were going to force me to spend any extra money on the ship ... especially money that was not theirs to begin with.After about 20 minutes and about two different managers I finally had the money taken off the shipboard account and refunded to me in cash.

The other negative thing that occurred was over a simple piece of fruit in the Opus Dining Room at our dinner service. On any other cruise I have been on, including the Celebrity Solstice in 2010, I have always enjoyed having papaya either before or after a dinner service. You would think that because papaya grows in the Caribbean, there would be a problem getting papaya.After all this is a tropical cruise and papaya is a tropical fruit. Try telling that to the Executive Chef that was on board the December 15th Eastern Caribbean Cruise.

The first might was not a problem and our waiter (Michael) which is probably the best waiter I have had on any cruise ship was able to deliver each night ... even after the Executive Chef denied serving it. It turns out that this Executive Chef had it in his mind that we were insulting his menu when in fact we were complimenting his menu with the papaya. This chef had no idea what customer service is supposed to be like on a cruise ship. People pay big money to travel on cruise ships and expect to have good service.It is not that I was asking for the Moon ... just a simple piece of fruit. This is the first cruise where I have ever had a meeting with the waiter, Maitre D, Restaurant Manager & Executive Chef. I was given a formal apology for the actions of the executive chef and was assured that he would be disciplined. I quickly stated that I have no issue with the chef and I do not want there to be any bad feelings or further discipline. Upon concluding this unscheduled meeting, we all shook hands. The only thing that I can point out is that the chef is the only one that did not look me in the eye when it came to shaking my hand. That goes to show the arrogance of this chef as he has no concept of personal relations.

Ironically we had room service deliver breakfast to us every morning so that we could enjoy in on our balcony on the top passenger deck and at the back of the
ship. Although not on the menu, we had generous portions of papaya served to us every morning without any issues.

As a positive foot note,the net result of this experience from this unscheduled meeting was a very large fruit platter that was in our room upon returning from the night. We received a daily delivery of fruit for being in a concierge class stateroom, but this plate was huge and as we later found out was courtesy of the restaurant manager.

Although we had these minor mishaps, this was a very enjoyable cruise except for missing out on Puerto Rico. The very positive that can be said about the entertainment in the theater, these were by far the best singers and entertainers that we have had on any cruise that we have had.

The only other Problem that I had with Celebrity was to compensate me for the transportation from Fort Lauderdale to the Miami Cruise Terminal. I did finally get through to Dana who was working on the front desk to help out with a taxi ride from the hotel of the last night in Miami to the Fort Lauderdale Airport. After many times of advising that Celebrity does not cover additional costs for transportation, she finally broke down and gave us $ 70.00 for the taxi ride. It ended up costing $75.00 for the taxi ride. It cost me $ 140.00 from the Ritz Carlton in Fort Lauderdale to the Miami Cruise Terminal though,that I am still out of pocket.

On the positive side though ... because it was Celebrity messed up our flight plans for the day of departure, they did cover us for a night's stay at the JW Marriott in Miami ( about a $285/nt room ). The reason for this is that we had planned to leave Fort Lauderdale on December 23rd. But,because the Reflection left one day earlier that the Silhouette, we still had one more full day either in Miami or Fort Lauderdale. Celebrity chose Miami.

All in all this was a verg good cruise. Because of some of the mishaps that we had, I cannot call this a great cruise like the one we had two years ago on the Celebrity Solstice on a Westen Caribbean cruise. That cruise was first class all the way !! Less

Published 01/21/13

Cabin review: C12214 Concierge Class

Room number 2214 is the room that we were in on this trip. The room is located on the top passenger deck in a C1 category and although not huge, is great for two people. This room has a very comfortable King Size bed that offers a great view from the back of the ship as the room is located in the dead center of the back of the ship. There are only two C1 categories on this deck so be sure to book your cruise early if you want this room. The nice thing about the balcony on this room and all of the other rooms that are on deck 12 at the back all have any overhanging deck from a restaurant above that covers the entire top of the balcony. That way if is is too hot or if it is raining, you can still be sheltered from the elements yet enjoy the balcony. It was great every morning by ordering room service and eating breakfast from a completely unobstructed ocean view that extended for almost 180 deg. This room can be a little noisy in the morning as you can hear people dragging chairs above. The view completely makes up for this minor inconvenience. Although there is no bathtub, the Handsgrove shower head makes up for no tub. Other than hearing some noise occasionally from the restaurant deck above, there are no noises from anyone in any of the other cabins and the ride is very smooth ... even in slightly rough waters. If you cannot get this specific room, any of the rooms on deck 12 would be recommended. The nice thing is that you do not have people looking down upon you.

Read All Concierge Class (C1) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

San Juan appeared to be a very beautiful city and port. But, after having our shore excursion cancelled and arriving later, I cannot give this a first class rating ... especially after being warned about the crime rate and not to wonder to much after dark. Why would they have an original arrival time of 3:00pm where my excursion could have been completed and I could have been back safely on the ship and then change the arrival time without notice?
Read 2952 San Juan Reviews

Beautiful island but chose the wrong shore excursion. Spent too much time at the zoo (1hr and 20min) when we could have been exploring the entire island. Our tour guide even asked the people on our tour what the most popular part of the island was. I whispered to my girlfriend the airport on the Dutch Side. No one had the answer and the tour operator said the " airport where the planes cross very closely to the beach ". Unbelievably we did not go there. At least I am going back to St Maarten this November. I will make my way over to the airport and the shopping districts on my own rather than waste my money on an excursion.

Have been to St Thomas quite a few times and did not want to take an excursion this time. If you have never been to St Thomas and are arriving by Cruise Ship, take the aerial tram. This will give you a fabulous view from about 800-1000' of the surrounding islands and of the cruise ships below. If you have never seen an iguana and are arriving by either Princess or Celebrity on the northern piers, you will see many of the iguanas sunning themselves along the rocks that are just off the main pier. One this that is beautiful about St Thomas is the water colour. Of all of the ports that we visited on this trip, St Thomas has by far the best water colour. In my opinion, of all of the ports that I have visited on my ventures to the Caribbean over the years, Bonnaire has the clearest water by a land slide.
Read 3995 St. Thomas Reviews

Compare Prices on Celebrity Reflection Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Celebrity Reflection cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Celebrity Reflection Review >>

Compare Prices on Celebrity Reflection Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2013
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Celebrity Reflection deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Celebrity Reflection 83% Loved It

10 Night Italy & Greek Isles Cruise
See all Celebrity Reflection Deals >>