Terrific crossing: Celebrity Silhouette Cruise Review by russg140

Celebrity Silhouette 5
Member Since 2005
433 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

Terrific crossing

Sail Date: December 2012
Destination: Transatlantic
Embarkation: Other
OK. There are enough reviews about the food, entertainment, staff, etc. that I don't need to say anything other than the aforementioned "departments" are totally subjective; what one person may find wonderful another may find boring. Having said that this review will go over some of the basic questions you may have about selecting Celebrity Cruises (and the Solstice Class ship).

First a little about us: gay couple in our late 40's. We cruise for good food and drink, relaxation, good service and tasteful atmosphere. We don't do the shows, activities, art auctions and casino. So:

Cabin: Inside, outside, balcony or suite? How much space do you want and what level of services do you require? We were in a Sky Suite which is a very large room, 1 1/2 size balcony, large bathroom and plenty of storage. Concierge and Aqua class? Are you going to use the services. It seems to us that the "perks" don't seem to justify the additional cost, but some travelers enjoy these More cabins. It depends on your budget.

Beverage packages: The idea that you drink more to "get your money's worth" is completely incorrect for the majority of people. So you have to figure out what and how much do you drink (not necessarily alcohol)? Take a look at your average vacation day consumption including mornings, afternoons, workout, and late night in addition to pre-dinner. Make sure to include bottled water, expresso-based beverages, soft drinks and wine. Calculate how much you are going to spend if you DON'T buy a drink package versus a drink package. Keep in mind soft drink only, wine only and coffee only packages are available too. In our situation one of us had: a bloody mary in the morning, a glass of wine or bottle of beer with lunch, large bottle of water for working out, latte in the afternoon, 2 drinks before dinner, wine with dinner and an after dinner drink and we felt the Classic Drink package gave us good value.Specialty Restaurants: We thought the food in the Cuvee Dining Room was generally excellent. If it wasn't our waiter didn't hesitate to offer an alternative. If we wanted more he didn't blink an eye. We do, however enjoy the restaurant feel offered by the Specialty Dining venues. Is the cost worth it? Yes. Keep in mind that very often you can get reduced prices on "the day of" as they try to fill open seats, but you may not get to eat at your desired time with this approach. If that doesn't matter, then wait until you're on board to book and see if you can get a deal. It's also important to remember that the staff in the Specialty Restaurants do NOT get a tip envelope at the end of the cruise, so make sure to tip them at the end of the meal.

Internet: Enough has been said about how slow the internet is. Yes, that's true and yes you do eat through your minutes faster than you do at home. That's just a fact of having access at sea. Should you buy a package? Yes. How much? That's based on expected use. If you think you're only going to access your email and maybe some news you may not need as many minutes. If you think you're going to upload pics to your FB page, watch movie clips of your grandkids blowing out their birthday candles, etc. you'll need more. Keep in mind you can always buy additional packages if you use up your minutes.

Shore excursions: These are on the pricey side BUT if you've never visited any or all of the ports you are visiting and don't have the opportunity to join a tour booked outside of the ships services then this is the way to go. We had never been to all but one of the ports we visited and signed up for 1/2 day excursions through Celebrity (booked when we got onboard). This allowed us the chance to go sightseeing, but still have time to explore the port on our own when we got back. Keep in mind that most shore excursions have you up and ready to go by 8:00 - 8:30, so you won't be able to sleep in.

Spa services: We didn't book anything because the services were REALLY expensive. If you want to indulge and have a some money handy go for it. The fitness center (complimentary use) is well equipped, so if you like a good workout take your gear.

Flights: How soon can you get off the ship? Play it on the safe side and allow yourself enough time to get off, get your bags, get through Customs and Immigration (if appropriate) and get a cab. Keep in mind that you're not the only one trying to get off and get to the airport. Should you use the transfer service provided by Celebrity? You're going to have to wait for everybody booked for the transfer to complete the above mentioned disembarkation tasks, which takes even more time. If you're the kind of person who is impatient and just wants to get to the airport, then pass. You may spend more money taking a cab, but you'll have the peace of mind of being in control of your own destiny.

OK. This is too long! If you have any other questions about cruising with Celebrity please feel free to email me at russg4willard@mac.com. Happy Cruising! Less

Published 12/20/12

Cabin review: S22123 Sky Suite

Read All Sky Suite (S2) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

Self-Guided Walking Tour

You picked up your iPod and accompanying map and set off to see the sites of Barcelona. Lots of great information and easy to follow. It was a great way to do a tour at your own pace. You could stop when you wanted to and skip other things that weren't of interest. The program was created for cruise ship passengers and the audio narrator reminds you of the need to leave enough time to return to the ship. Lots of fun.

Pisa Walking Tour

Left on time. Guide was fairly knowledgeable. Our group wasn't scheduled to enter the Tower until 12:00 and the guide seemed annoyed that we had to kill time until then, so he gave us "free time". We explored the other buildings in the area which were very interesting then we walked up the Tower.

Portofino Walking Tour

Short bus ride to meet up with a ferry to take us to Portofino. Guide provided us with some information about the area to and from the ferry. Once at Portofino we walked around a bit then had some time on our own. Since we were there after the season a lot was closed, but you could imagine what a hopping place it must be in the summer.


Great guide. Very knowledgeable and informative both going to Aix and returning. Once we arrived in Aix our guide gave us the permission to leave the walking tour at any time and explore on our own, provided we return to the meeting point at the assigned time. We walked off the beaten path and found a local market - loaded up on olive oil, herbs, lavender, soaps, etc. Lots of fun. Once back we explored the town of Sevigne sur Mer (?) where the ship was docked. Kind of down on it's heels, but walk around a bit then back on the ship.

Compare Prices on Celebrity Silhouette Transatlantic Cruises

Read more Celebrity Silhouette cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Celebrity Silhouette Review >>

Compare Prices on Celebrity Silhouette Transatlantic Cruises

Member Since 2005
433 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Skip X

See Celebrity Silhouette deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
Celebrity Silhouette 81% Loved It

12 Night Western Mediterranean Cruise
See all Celebrity Silhouette Deals >>