We went on the Fantasy just after Thanksgiving 2012. This was our first time cruising and we chose this ship because of the port convenience to our home and the possibility of saving some money.
Overall we had a positive experience and would definately cruise again.
Embarkation: We got there early due to great service from our "Stay and Sail" package at the Hampton Inn at Isle of Palms. Embarkation was pretty smooth and fast (other than a search of a couple of our carryons.) Having pre-regiatered online really smoothed the process and having only carryons worked fairly well, although a tad bulky to keep with us while we waited for room to be ready.
Low center of ship, above gangplank and thus, noisy. Oceanview with full window, not porthole. Near one set of elevators.