Carnival Victory delivers 6 islands in 7 days: Carnival Victory Cruise Review by the bruin and the duck

Carnival Victory 3
the bruin and the duck
Member Since 2012

Overall Member Rating

Carnival Victory delivers 6 islands in 7 days

Sail Date: November 2012
Destination: Southern Caribbean
Embarkation: San Juan
On our second ever cruise, my husband and I decided to do something different from Alaska (our first) and go to the Carribean!

Like most people we talked to on the Carnival Victory, the itinerary for this ship is the draw for most visiting 5 different islands with a departure port of San Juan for the 6th island visit. We had never been to any of these islands and were very excited for the itinerary.

This review is only for the ship (I'll do separate port reviews) for each island.

The good:

-The room stewards were all very friendly, always greeting us with various salutations throughout the time there and our steward always addressed us by our names.

-Towel service at the Serenity Adult Only Space was a nice convenience

-Sauna, steam room, and fitness facility was in great condition

-Your time dining gave you great flexibility but of course this means you don't get the same waiter every time you dine which we were fine More with.

-Having healthy eating options on the menu was definitely a plus

The mediocore:

Serenity Whirlpool-Having an adult only space was definitely a pro but the material the whirlpool was made out of was this thick cheap looking plastic.

Entertainment-overall decent, but nothing to write home about. Comedians were horrible though, see below.

Food-In the Pacific Dining Room it wasn't bad. The menu varied each night with certain staples every night. The molten lava cake and cheese plates were very good dessert options. The appetizers on a whole were also very good. Lobster was available on the first formal night. Filet mignon (way overcooked) also available on a different night. We generally didn't eat at the buffets in the evening although we did participate in the midnight mexican buffet. Overally the buffet food quantity definitely exceed the quality. For breakfast the scrambled eggs were not palatable so we always ordered omlettes or eggs cooked to order. It was nice to have food available-although the pizza was terrible, the chicken tenders were quite good.

Having 2 formal nights is really random. We dressed up for the first one like 90% of the ship participated in that one but for the second formal night, it went the other way with only 10% of the ship dressed up. It's the carribean so people were definitely dressed pretty casual on a whole.

The bad:

Noise level-We had to call security once to quiet down our neighbors who were so loud at 12:30am on the first night that they woke us up! The cabin walls are really thin. Another time we heard a couple fighting pretty loudly and we could hear their whole argument just walking through the hallway.

Comedians-they ranged from unfunny to terribly unfunny; the best act was actually the juggler surprisingly.

Cabins-For those thinking of getting an aft cabin, be aware there is a trade off. Sure the cabin is more spacious, but every morning when the ship pulls into port and every afternoon when the ship leaves, the whole cabin rumbles for a good 5-10 minutes leaving for some very uncomfortable moments. Booker beware!

Overall tips:

-cab ride to port from airport is about $24

-they let you on board as early as 12 noon and offer a buffet lunch

-you must be back on the ship by 9:00pm

-you can bring a whole case of water on board; there were only 2 of us and we brought a 24 bottle pack with no problem

-The whirlpools were very busy right around 4:30-6:30 but it dies down after that

-the lines outside by the pool for breakfast buffet seem to be quite a bit shorter than the lines inside.

-don't waste too much time going on the land tours-hit the beach! Less

Published 11/21/12

Cabin review: 6B2457 Ocean View

Cabin 2457-For those thinking of getting an aft cabin, be aware there is a trade off. Sure the cabin is more spacious, but every morning when the ship pulls into port and every afternoon when the ship leaves, the whole cabin rumbles for a good 5-10 minutes leaving for some very uncomfortable moments. Booker beware =)

Read All Ocean View (6B) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

Catamaran Tour

Loved Barbados-clearest turquoise waters with glistening powder white sand. Swam with turtles and snorkeled around shipwrecks. Booked catamaran tour with SilverMoon for 12 person catamaran ($115/per person which is more than the cruise ship price @ $99) but you get more space. Limited snorkeling time with turtles though. Relaxing day at sea and would recommend! Free wifi at the visitor center which is convenient! Carlisle Bay is a must visit if you don't do the catamaran just make your way there for the gorgeous beach.

San Juan is great-make sure to check out El Morro and the Cristobal Fort; stroll the streets in San Juan. Try some local specialties like mofongo and Puerto Rican coffe @ Cafe Colao'o (right next to port). We didn't get a chance to see the beaches this time but heard great things about Isla Verde and Luquello.

Read 2982 San Juan Reviews

Took a taxi ride to Carambola (South Friar's Beach) $4/per person for shared cab ride of 4+persons. Quiet and calm, pricey food and chair/umbrella rentals ($10/each rental) but overall great serene experience and very clean facility. Tranquility was very valued with no vendors on the beach!! We heard from others that Cockleshell was nothing compared to this. One of our favorite days on the cruise.

Read 1323 St. Kitts Reviews

Booked an all day tour with Cosol for $65/person. Drove around the island for 7 hours seeing various sites. Not recommended for those who are prone to car sickness as roads are really windy. Highlights of the trip were trying the local snacks and taking the water taxi to Jalouise Plantation Beach. I'm indifferent about this tour because so much of your time is spent in the car. We really didn't get too much time to see a nice beach. The Jalouise plantation beach is a very small strip.

Read 1137 St. Lucia Reviews

Taxi rides are pricey! We spent $65 going to 3 different places. If you could rent a car it would be ideal as the roads here were well paved and out of all the islands this one seemed most developed and populated.

Orient Beach was fun-went to both sides although beach was better in Barbados and St. Kitts (high surf at Orient). This beach was much more of a party beach in general.

Maho Beach/Sunset Beach-great if you want to see planes land. Small strip of beach but water was clear and sand was soft.

Marigot-good for shopping and eating lunch

Locals/cab drivers were the least friendly on this island compared to all our other ports.

French influence very apparent on the island which was really neat.

City Tour

We went to Blackbeard's castle ($14 admission/per person is steep for what you get to see. We cannot recommend this.

We also did a city tour for $30 where we saw a few photo ops and went to the banana daquiri place.

We opted to go to Coki Beach over Meghan's Bay because we only had 2 hours (part of the tour). If you remember one thing, it is this, do not go to Coki Beach. That was my singular biggest regret of the whole trip was having to spend 2 hours there. Meghan's Bay and or Sapphire Beach would be much better choices.

Having gone on the tour I cannot recommend it either-it was rather boring unless you are a history buff although our tour operator Godfrey was nice enough. I would recommend just spending a day at the beach.

Compare Prices on Carnival Victory Southern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Victory cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Victory Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Victory Southern Caribbean Cruises

the bruin and the duck
Member Since 2012
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Skip X

See Carnival Victory deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
Carnival Victory 71% Loved It

3 Day Bahamas Itinerary
See all Carnival Victory Deals >>